Best Drywall & Plaster Contractors in Toms River, NJ

15 companies listed · 5 in Toms River · 1 open 24/7 · 11 open weekends · 12 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 3, 2026

Pro-Custom Drywall LLC

Pro-Custom Drywall LLC

4.9 80 reviews
“PCD responded very fast when I reached out to them for drywall and insulation repairs in my kitchen ceiling.”
Free consultationLicensed & insuredSince 2018Serves Toms River, Brick +2Family-owned
219 Dayton Ave
i
Proedge Painting

Proedge Painting

5.0 107 reviews
“They were professional, efficient and neat and I would highly recommend them for whatever job you need done.”
10% off all servicesFree estimatesInsured & bonded1-yr warrantyServes Toms River, Brick +3Licensed
1371 Bridport Dr
i
Mr. Ryan Painting Llc.

Mr. Ryan Painting Llc.

4.6 27 reviews
“They had great eye for all details and were attentive to anything I wanted done.”
Free consultationInsured12,000+ clients servedServes Ocean County, Monmouth CountyLicensedSince 2020
Jackson, NJ · 13 mi from Toms River
i
Atlantic Sheetrock / Drywall

Atlantic Sheetrock / Drywall

4.7 89 reviews
“Very professional, punctual, neat, personable and most of all great work.”
104 Keats Ave
i
Johnson's Home & Business Services

Johnson's Home & Business Services

5.0 5 reviews
“He does amazing work and you are missing out if you have not worked with him yet!”
Since 1986Serves Toms River, Manchester +2Family-ownedOpen 24 hours
592 Sica Ln
i
Jim's Painting

Jim's Painting

5.0 11 reviews
“This is the second job Jim has done for me and the quality and professionalism is superb.”
Free estimates35+ yearsServes Ocean County, Monmouth County +5
1165 Audubon Dr
i

Listed for homeowners in and around Toms River, NJ, these 15 companies hang, tape and finish drywall. What each states about repairs, texture matching and new construction work comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Toms River, NJ

5 of the 15 companies we list are based in Toms River; the other 10 serve Toms River from towns including Brick (6 mi), Jackson (13 mi) and Beachwood (4 mi). 14 of the companies on this page have a rating, from 4.0 to 5.0 across 784 reviews; 5 have 50 or more reviews and 12 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these companies on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (100%), quality (100%) and punctuality (96%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "price", "cleanliness" and "crew". 1 is open around the clock; 11 are open on Saturdays and 5 on Sundays. The services the companies on this page list most often on their websites are exterior painting (2), interior painting (2) and power washing (2). 4 show a license on their websites and 1 has a BBB rating of A or A+. 8 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 32 years. 1 offers emergency call-outs; 7 give free estimates and 5 are family- or locally-owned. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book.

Does drywall and plaster work need licensing?

4 of the 15 listings show a license on their websites. Requirements vary by state, and some places license drywall work while others only require a general contractor registration above a certain job size. Whatever is named on a website is a claim you can check with the issuing board before hiring.

Omni Painting

Omni Painting

5.0 57 reviews
“William and his team did an amazing job fixing all of my wall and trim imperfections before painting and the finished product looks beautiful.”
Insured & bondedServes Monmouth County, Ocean CountyFree consultationSince 2018
Lanoka Harbor, NJ · 9 mi from Toms River
i
Book onlineBook
Carfagno Professional Painting LLC

Carfagno Professional Painting LLC

4.9 144 reviews
“They painted our red bricks white on the exterior of the home, trim around the house, Epoxy on the garage floor, painted the garage, painted a fiberglass deck, and power washed.”
Free estimatesNew Jersey license #13VH11150000Insured & bonded20+ yearsServes Ocean County, NJ, Monmouth County, NJFamily-owned
Beachwood, NJ · 4 mi from Toms River
i
J.A. Painting & Decorations LLC

J.A. Painting & Decorations LLC

4.1 12 reviews
“Finally, we had to wait to finish the kitchen after the backsplash was installed and he was even willing to wait 4 months ( until the tile came in) to come back and finish painting the trim on the cabinets.”
Free estimatesInsuredSince 1997Serves Monmouth County, Ocean CountyFamily-ownedBBB accredited
Jackson, NJ · 13 mi from Toms River
i
Wood's Home Improvement LLC

Wood's Home Improvement LLC

5.0 22 reviews
“I would not hesitate to hire Dave again for any other projects around my house.”
New Jersey license #13VH1262390025+ yearsServes Jersey Shore areaBBB accreditedInsurance accepted
Brick, NJ · 6 mi from Toms River
i
Bulldog Painting

Bulldog Painting

4.8 23 reviews
“This company is very easy to work with and they were able to help us on a holiday weekend in order for us to move into our new home freshly painted.”
Free consultationSince 2010
Howell, NJ · 13 mi from Toms River
i
Tom's Drywall Inc

Tom's Drywall Inc

4.9 34 reviews
“Got me a quote and work started in a very timely manor.”
Brick, NJ · 6 mi from Toms River
i
Perfect Stucco Enterprises Inc.

Perfect Stucco Enterprises Inc.

5.0 1 review
Since 2007
Lakewood, NJ · 6 mi from Toms River
i
Fine Finishing Drywall

Fine Finishing Drywall

Since 1995
Brick, NJ · 6 mi from Toms River
i
Keefe Drywall & Painting

Keefe Drywall & Painting

LicensedSince 2017Virtual consultations
Manasquan, NJ · 11 mi from Toms River
i
HomeDrywall & Plaster ContractorsNew JerseyToms River, NJ

Why these companies made our list

What customers say about companies in and near Toms River

  • “I will be using them for future projects and would recommend to anyone in need of drywall services.” — customer of Pro-Custom Drywall LLC
  • “Without a doubt Carl is the most professional drywall contractor we had the pleasure of working with.” — customer of Atlantic Sheetrock / Drywall
  • “I would definitely recommend Tom's Drywall. They did great work, were efficient and reasonably priced.” — customer of Tom's Drywall Inc
  • “They did a beautiful job with my drywall repairs - meticulous, truly meticulous.” — customer of Pro-Custom Drywall LLC

Excerpts from public reviews of the companies listed on this page.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top