Best Property Managers in Fort Collins, CO

18 companies listed · all 18 in Fort Collins · 2 open 24/7 · 5 open weekends · 11 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 26, 2026

Stegner Property Management

Stegner Property Management

4.4 104 reviews
“From our first inquiry with Silas—during the height of COVID when finding a good rental felt nearly impossible—to Shelby's thoughtful accommodation of our request to move out early due to a change in our life circumstances, they have dealt with us fairly, communicated clearly, and been incredibly reasonable.”
BBB ASince 2012
1020 Luke St # B
i
Kyle Basnar

Kyle Basnar

5.0 91 reviews
“Kyle researched specific houses with similar floor plans that recently sold in our neighborhood to understand buyer feedback and prepare for what we would likely hear from buyers and also to understand the interest and get an idea of what to expect from offers”
Open 24 hoursSince 2016
401 W Mulberry St
i
Real Property Management

Real Property Management

4.6 128 reviews
“I really enjoy renting from this property not only are they always on top of everything but they respond to messages instantly when they can they do a great job and keeping the resident happy and they do a great job with keeping the property looking great if you're looking for a place to rent or buy through I recommend them!”
BBB A+Since 2007Prices online
1220 Oak Park Dr
i
Carousel Properties

Carousel Properties

4.9 88 reviews
“Great place to stay for a traveling business person I stayed 6 month and it was great very quiet and convenient to restaurants and shopping the only thing you need to bring is your clothes everything is included great wifi and for a winter traveler the garage for your vehicle was super if I return to ft Collins I will definitely stay here”
Since 1997Family-owned
4920 Mcmurry Ave P3
i
All County the Fort Collins Team Property Management

All County the Fort Collins Team Property Management

4.5 110 reviews
“From helping us to find a good handyman, who was essential in our efforts to prepare the house for the rental market, to quickly finding a dependable tenant, and ongoing maintenance, All County has made everything easy.”
Since 2003
1027 W Horsetooth Rd Suite F208
i
Middel Realty

Middel Realty

4.7 58 reviews
“Any issues with the house were addressed immediately usually that day or the following and with their level of professionalism and experience as land-lords they fully understand the difference between normal wear and tear on a house as opposed to someone who is abusing the place.”
Since 2001Family-owned
1407 S College Ave
i

Listed for property owners in and around Fort Collins, CO, these 18 companies manage rental property. What each says about the property types it takes, the services in its fee and its license is drawn from its own website, next to ratings and quotes from public reviews.

Area overview: Fort Collins, CO

All 18 companies we list here are in Fort Collins itself. 17 of the companies on this page have a rating, from 3.4 to 5.0 across 2,028 reviews; 7 have 50 or more reviews and 11 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "communication" and "responsive". 2 are open around the clock and 5 are open on weekends. 4 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 14 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 40 years. 2 offer emergency call-outs and 4 are family- or locally-owned. We have a website on file for all 18 of the companies on this page; 16 publish a contact page; 11 list a public email and 1 takes bookings online. We count these figures across the companies on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book.

Do any property managers listed for Fort Collins take overnight calls?

Around the clock cover is stated by 2 of the 18 companies on this page. For an owner that phone line is the product, because a burst supply line at 3 a.m. is your loss and not the tenant's. Ask who actually picks up, whether it is an answering service, and which trades can be sent out overnight.

Casa Realty and Property Management

Casa Realty and Property Management

4.9 26 reviews
“Matt stays on top of everything including, but not limited to, updating each units, maintenance and repairs, performing city required inspections periodically, effectively communicating plans to each party, leasing out the vacant units timely, renewing leases if need, etc.”
Since 2021Locally ownedPrices online
2580 E Harmony Rd Unit 201
i
Places Realty

Places Realty

4.2 84 reviews
“I started with Places Realty as a rental client & had a bad experience with a home owner (I will make sure I don't work with Brett Myatt again, who is also in Realty through Places according to their website but they claim he doesn't work there, not sure how that works) but as for Lisa & her actual team they are nice & professional.”
Since 1986
515 S Sherwood St
i
Kurt's Property Management & Investments Ltd

Kurt's Property Management & Investments Ltd

4.2 24 reviews
“We experienced a severe windstorm that caused significant damage to our fence, and our neighbors were super rude, acting as though we were responsible for the storm and intentionally delaying the fence's repair to inconvenience them.”
Since 2000
3307 Citation Ct
i
Mascot Property Management

Mascot Property Management

5.0 17 reviews
“He recently helped save us over $10K by taking the time to re-submit a new roof to our insurance company, a claim which they had previously declined and we had thought was a lost cause.”
Since 2023Family-ownedPrices online
916 Ponderosa Dr
i
Cobblestone Realty Fort Collins & Northern Colorado

Cobblestone Realty Fort Collins & Northern Colorado

5.0 4 reviews
“I have bought many rental units and my personal residence from the owner of Coblestone Realty, Kevin Barrier.”
BBB A+Since 2002
3131 S College Ave
i
Rentpro Property Management

Rentpro Property Management

4.8 11 reviews
“Josh and Mitchell have made my renting experience easy and stress free with their proactive and respectful communication, transparency, and flexibility with me as a tenant.”
Since 2019Prices online
11 Old Town Square #250
i
Trunoco Property Management & Real Estate

Trunoco Property Management & Real Estate

4.5 8 reviews
“With top notch tenant screening they will protect the property condition, give accurate rental pricing and work with tenants in a fair yet effective manner.”
Since 2023
736 Whalers Way Bldg G Suite #110-3
i
The Property Management Co.

The Property Management Co.

5.0 4 reviews
“Kris Aliabadi is great at keeping me in the loop every step of the rental process and very responsive to any question or concern we had along the way.”
Open 24 hoursSince 2004
1926 Silvergate Rd
i
Jensen Property Management Inc

Jensen Property Management Inc

4.0 1 review
“Secretary was very efficient at her job and I felt like l was important.”
Since 2010
1001 E Harmony Rd
i
Fort Collins Real Estate

Fort Collins Real Estate

4.2 3 reviews
“Mike has a lot of knowledge of the area, and can help you find what you are looking for.”
Since 2003
500 E Oak St
i
Metro District Management

Metro District Management

Since 2015
2619 Canton Ct
i
Westwind Management Group

Westwind Management Group

3.4 9 reviews
“As a home owner who resided in a different state, and who endured a number of difficult situations that were the result of poor execution by our property manager - I really value competency.”
Since 1999
3926 John F Kennedy Pkwy UNIT 9E
i
HomeProperty ManagersColoradoFort Collins, CO

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top