View Profile
Advantage Property Management
- Money
- Fee
- Call
“They let us be a part of decision making and heard our inputs on paint, yard landscaping ideas and looked into possible improvements for us with the owner.”
Best Property Managers in Santa Maria, CA
24 companies listed · 9 in Santa Maria · 6 open weekends · 15 rated 4.5+ · 11 show a license
Data verified October 15, 2026
View Profile
Silveira Properties
- Tenants
- Rent
“I would recommend Silveira Properties to anyone who is looking for a property manager who is responsible and will go above and beyond to ensure both the property owner and tenant are completely satisfied.”
View Profile
Walker & Associates Property Management
- Tenants
- Call
- Rent
“They have a high level of professionalism, combined with warm and personable staff, including the sub-contractors they use for things like plumbing (Matt's Plumbing is the BEST).”
View Profile
Property Manager
- Call
- Rented
- Tenants
“Both are very attentive to our new and wants (they're helping us to rent out a room in our house) they do so the background checks and all the paperwork.”
View Profile
New America Realty
- Patient
- Home
- Team
“Her and her team made the process easy and she worked with me every step of the way from start to finish to help me complete my most recent real estate venture.”
View Profile
Haven Property Management
“You can tell she loves what she does and cares about the people she is working with!”
Listed for property owners in and around Santa Maria, CA, these 24 companies manage rental property. What each says about the property types it takes, the services in its fee and its license is drawn from its own website, next to ratings and quotes from public reviews.
Area overview: Santa Maria, CA
Of the 24 companies we list here, 9 are in Santa Maria itself and 15 come from towns including Arroyo Grande (5, 14 mi), Nipomo (2, 8 mi) and Grover Beach (2, 16 mi). 22 of the companies on this page have a rating, from 4.0 to 5.0 across 464 reviews; 3 have 50 or more reviews and 15 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "knowledge" and "communication". 6 are open on Saturdays and 4 on Sundays. 11 show a license on their websites. Domain records put 16 websites of the companies on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1996. 1 offers emergency call-outs; 1 gives free estimates and 1 is family- or locally-owned. We have a website on file for all 24 of the companies on this page; 17 publish a contact page and 18 list a public email. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book.
Are these management companies based in Santa Maria?
9 of the 24 companies give an address in Santa Maria, and the others come from other towns within 35 mi. Distance counts for more here than in most trades, since somebody has to drive over for an inspection or a lockout. Ask how often they visit properties at your end of the area.
View Profile
Bartlein & Co Inc
“Great experience renting with you.”
View Profile
Central Coast Property Management
View Profile
EPM Construction
“I was already in a great company whom I had happily been with for over 6 years but decided to make the move after interviewing with both the representatives of the company.”
View Profile
Help-u-Sell Santa Maria
“Nathan Douglas with his vast knowledge, and network of people he has makes a”
View Profile
Valley Hills Realty
View Profile
Fisher Real Estate and Rentals
- Knowledge
- Home
- Interest
“Yvonne and Robert are great communicators, they know the market, they had trusted contractors to help us prepare our property for renters, and they followed up with us regularly.”
View Profile
Kilpelainen Property Management
- Honest
- Team
- Buyer
“The Kilpelainens are an amazing team that will give you an honest helping hand with navigating through a complicated and sometimes intimidating process.”
View Profile
Bey Property Solutions
- Space Heater
- Question
- Realtor
“Ron, the owner of The HVAC company (hotaircoldair) came out, fixed my heater less than an hour and was so kind, knowledgeable and very respectful of my home.”
View Profile
Crown Properties
“I've dealt with numerous property managers over the years, but none come close to the high level of responsibility, professionalism, personal concern and efficiency of Kaye Addington and her staff.”
View Profile
Nipomo Property Management
“Friendly staff and gets things done.”
View Profile
Pismo Property Management
- Vacation
- Rent
“We've been with Pismo Properties for quite awhile now (>5 yrs), and we're very happy with their service.”
View Profile
Forde Properties and Construction
“I have always had great business interactions with them broker to broker.”
View Profile
Searchlight Properties
- Lease
“We have never had to deal with a property management before and we were nervous, because we had contact other property managements and oh my they were rude and disrespectful.”
View Profile
Hoamco Central Coast
“Sam and the Hoamco team are great partners, and help our community with many issues with true professionalism.”
View Profile
California Property Services
“Great costumer service”
View Profile
Brenda Auer
View Profile
Invest SLO
- Chelsea
- Home
- Transaction
“I say this because in my situation I had an issue where I needed legal advice and she was able to reach out to her resources and handled it in the most professional way.”
View Profile
American Stages Realty & Management
- Home
- Team
- Communication
“American Stages Realty & Management strives on doing their best in every aspect of rental business such as screening for good tenants, rental property maintenance, ample knowledge of rental regulations, and so on.”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
