Best Property Managers in Tallahassee, FL

18 companies listed · all 18 in Tallahassee · 2 open weekends · 10 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 18, 2026

Picht & Sons Real Estate

Picht & Sons Real Estate

4.9 136 reviews
“During the turnover process, he seamlessly coordinated all of the necessary work through his trusted vendors, personally inspected the progress, kept everything on schedule, and brought valuable local real estate expertise to help me make practical decisions along the way”
BBB A+Since 2002
265 Pinewood Dr
i
Rent With Integrity

Rent With Integrity

4.2 111 reviews
“He arrived on time, answered our questions, and made sure we felt comfortable during the viewing.”
Since 2012
1648 Metropolitan Cir
i
Tallahassee Management & Leasing Group

Tallahassee Management & Leasing Group

4.5 41 reviews
“They really care about their tenants, very fair, always quick on repairs and communication was always there.”
Since 2013
1530 Metropolitan Blvd #108
i
Proper-T Management Services

Proper-T Management Services

4.3 130 reviews
“I've been renting a home in Jacksonville through Proper-T management services since June and have had a great experience.”
Since 2023
3233 Thomasville Rd
i
Pentwell

Pentwell

4.7 38 reviews
“Sam took time to answer all questions, he was very detailed in making sure everything worked.”
Since 2023
522 E Jefferson St
i
Gtwo Property Services

Gtwo Property Services

4.1 27 reviews
“The unit I lived in had virtually no issues moving in and when an issue did come up, GTWO had maintenance come out quickly.”
Since 2016
1210 Miccosukee Rd #2
i

Listed for property owners in and around Tallahassee, FL, these 18 companies manage rental property. What each says about the property types it takes, the services in its fee and its license is drawn from its own website, next to ratings and quotes from public reviews.

Area overview: Tallahassee, FL

All 18 companies we list here are in Tallahassee itself. We have 20 companies in Tallahassee on file; this page shows the highest-rated 18. The companies on this page are rated from 3.0 to 5.0 across 1,813 reviews; 6 have 50 or more reviews and 10 are rated 4.5 or higher. 2 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. 1 has a BBB rating of A or A+. 12 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 37 years. 1 gives free estimates. We have a website on file for 17 of the companies on this page; 13 publish a contact page; 13 list a public email and 1 takes bookings online. We count these figures across the companies on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book.

Vine Residential

Vine Residential

4.9 15 reviews
“They are on top of any request I have, and it's nice that it's real people/local owners, not some big absentee corporation!”
Since 2023Virtual consultations
1000 Thomasville Rd
i
Main Street Real Estate Group

Main Street Real Estate Group

3.5 35 reviews
“It has been an amazing experience and great peace of mind to know that the team is taking care of my property.”
Since 2011
626 E Park Ave
i
Onesource Property Management & Consulting

Onesource Property Management & Consulting

5.0 8 reviews
“Communication has been clear and timely, and any maintenance requests are handled quickly and efficiently.”
Since 2022
3370 Capital Cir NE suite b
i
Larson Park Realty

Larson Park Realty

5.0 5 reviews
“She has been responsive and pragmatic and has improved the overall management of our association greatly.”
Since 2014
216 W College Ave
i
Sunbelt Asset Management

Sunbelt Asset Management

4.2 3 reviews
“Upon moving out my entire security deposit was returned minus a cleaning charge that was discussed prior to move-out.”
Since 2015
B, 2639 N Monroe St Suite 101
i
My HOA Services

My HOA Services

5.0 1 review
“Response time with any inquiry is handled with the upmost importance and unbelievably quick.”
Since 2015
1615 Village Square Blvd Suite 3 Suite 3, Office 1
i
SR Companies

SR Companies

Since 2021
1589 Metropolitan Blvd
i
St James Certified Prop Management

St James Certified Prop Management

4.0 6 reviews
“Doc isn't afraid to go the extra mile for you and deliver outstanding customer service with each interaction.”
Since 1999
2570 Noble Dr
i
Executive Management Service

Executive Management Service

Free consultationSince 2017
719 E Park Ave
i
NAI Talcor Commercial Real Estate & Property Management

NAI Talcor Commercial Real Estate & Property Management

3.8 6 reviews
“Helpful commercial real estate firm with vast knowledge of the North Florida market.”
Since 2012
1018 Thomasville Rd #200a
i
FLV Inc

FLV Inc

Since 2005
2928 Wellington Cir Ste 201
i
Burt Reynolds Hall

Burt Reynolds Hall

5.0 2 reviews
“Butch “The Mantanince Man” Was VERY Polite & Reminded Me Of Home & That Was Very Important To Me Cause You're Allowing A Random Man Come In To Your Home To Fix Things but He Was Very Nice & Also Gave Me His Contact Just In Case I Needed Him For Anything Else.”
Since 1989
2065 Delta Way STE 2
i
HomeProperty ManagersFloridaTallahassee, FL

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top