Best Drywall & Plaster Contractors near Oyster Bay, NY
1 of these companies is based in Oyster Bay; the others serve Oyster Bay from towns including Hicksville (2 mi), Plainview (3 mi) and Kingston, MA (6 mi).
4 open 24/7 · 14 open weekends · all 15 rated 4.5+ · 7 show a license
Data verified October 18, 2026
Oyster Drywall Repair & Installation
Elite Painting Services Plus
“He answered all of my questions and was always quick to respond.”
Green Apple Painting
“Joe is quick, responsive, and fair on the business end and Blake is a knowledgeable painter and very friendly guy who did a fantastic job in our home.”
Masse Group Painting
“Especially helpful was the sharing of knowledge/advice received along the way which reduced the anxiety that comes along with home projects.”
Long Island Painting Company
“We have used Walker Painting a number of times for painting jobs in our house, Including earlier today when they painted the floor in my unfinished basement and part of the ceiling in my basement.”
Listed for homeowners in and around Oyster Bay, NY, these 15 companies hang, tape and finish drywall. What each states about repairs, texture matching and new construction work comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Oyster Bay, NY
The 15 companies on this page are rated from 4.8 to 5.0 across 1,190 reviews; 9 have 50 or more reviews. When customers rate these companies on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (93%), quality (92%) and responsiveness (86%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "estimates", "cleanliness" and "price". 4 are open around the clock; 14 are open on Saturdays and 9 on Sundays. The services the companies on this page list most often on their websites are exterior painting (4), cabinet painting (2), cabinet refinishing (2), commercial painting (2) and drywall (2). 7 show a license on their websites; 1 lists staff certifications (EPA) and 2 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 10 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 31 years. 4 offer emergency call-outs; 9 give free estimates and 4 are family- or locally-owned. We have a website on file for 14 of the companies on this page; 13 publish a contact page and 10 list a public email. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book.
Will anyone quote a small repair for free?
9 of the 15 listings state free estimates. For one small patch the trip costs more than the work, so expect a minimum charge rather than an hourly rate. Save up the jobs: a ceiling stain, two dented corners and a doorway crack together are worth a visit and price better than one at a time.
Bigexpert Painting LLC
“Very reasonable price very good and professional at what they do 100% recommend to anyone”
South Shore Painting
“Recently, Eddie and his team painted the main level of my house as well as changed the color in my guest bedroom.”
Turner's Painting LLC
“Wayne gave us a reasonable quote and was onsite the very next day to begin work.”
Final Touch Painting & Decorating
“The painting that Bruce and his team did for my apartment was amazing!”
JAT Painters INC
“They're not an inexpensive painting contractor like I thought, BUT they're fully insured which makes me much more comfortable to choose them.”
Silva's Painting
“They transformed walls and ceilings that to me looked problematic at best, into something that looks amazingly new.”
Pride Painting & Spackling Home Improvement
“Brian did an amazing job repairing the drywall around a recently installed bathroom medicine cabinet and painting of the damaged area.”
PCF Coatings
“Showed up everyday on time and very very professional , my house looks like brand new.”
PNP Craftsmen
“We had kitchen cabinets painted, with small repairs, and it call came out flawlessly, and it now looks like we did a complete overhaul of the kitchen that would have cost many times the price paid.”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
