Best Drywall & Plaster Contractors near Bay Shore, NY

1 of these companies is based in Bay Shore; the others serve Bay Shore from towns including Huntington (11 mi), Amityville (9 mi) and East Islip (4 mi).

1 open 24/7 · 14 open weekends · 14 rated 4.5+ · 6 show a license

Data verified November 4, 2026

B & B Painting By the Pro's

B & B Painting By the Pro's

4.9 28 reviews
“Brad and his crew are the best !!”
BBB A+Since 2004
287 Lombardy Blvd
i
Green Apple Painting & Wallpaper

Green Apple Painting & Wallpaper

4.9 103 reviews
“Did phenomenal work putting up a wallpaper mural in my dining room.”
Free consultationOpen 24 hoursSince 2013Family-ownedCash only
Greenwich, CT · 31 mi from Bay Shore
i
The Paint Pros

The Paint Pros

5.0 81 reviews
“Not only was the work impeccable, but the professionalism and communication throughout the process were outstanding.”
Licensed & insuredResponds within 24 hoursServes Suffolk County, NY, Long IslandFamily-ownedFree consultationBBB accredited
Bohemia, NY · 8 mi from Bay Shore
i
Valdez Painting Co.

Valdez Painting Co.

4.9 65 reviews
“Thay did a wonderful job clean as possible while working, the workers were nice to be around no problems will have them do more work in the future.”
Free phone consultation32+ yearsServes Huntington, NY
Amityville, NY · 9 mi from Bay Shore
i
La Clave Home Improvements

La Clave Home Improvements

5.0 69 reviews
“We are very satisfied with how beautiful it all turned out, and will absolutely recommend LACLAVE for your painting needs.”
Free consultationLicensedSince 2020Family-owned
Farmingdale, NY · 10 mi from Bay Shore
i
Turner's Painting LLC

Turner's Painting LLC

5.0 51 reviews
“Wayne and his team were easy to work with and did a great job painting.”
Free consultationLicensedSince 2008
Huntington, NY · 11 mi from Bay Shore
i

Listed for homeowners in and around Bay Shore, NY, these 15 companies hang, tape and finish drywall. What each states about repairs, texture matching and new construction work comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Hiring a drywall contractor near Bay Shore

The 15 companies on this page are rated from 4.0 to 5.0 across 897 reviews; 7 have 50 or more reviews and 14 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "price" and "cleanliness". We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book.

In New York

  • Home improvement contractors must be licensed in New York City and in Suffolk, Nassau, Westchester, Putnam and Rockland counties.
  • Your home improvement contract must be in writing, legible and in plain English, with a copy given to you before any work is done.
  • You can cancel a home improvement contract in writing, for any reason, until midnight of the third business day after you sign.

Attorney General fact sheet and Attorney General hiring guide, checked November 2026

Does drywall and plaster work need licensing?

6 of the 15 listings show a license on their websites. Requirements vary by state, and some places license drywall work while others only require a general contractor registration above a certain job size. Whatever is named on a website is a claim you can check with the issuing board before hiring.

New York rules for hiring a contractor
Conrad Painting

Conrad Painting

5.0 41 reviews
“Conrad hits it on all cylinders - I have dealt with tons of painters and construction trades and this guy takes the cake - QUALITY WORK- EASY TO COMMUNICATE- RESPECTFUL & TALENTED - use him and you will refer him all day long.....”
Free estimatesSince 2008Serves Suffolk County, Nassau CountyFamily-owned
Huntington, NY · 11 mi from Bay Shore
i
South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC

5.0 238 reviews
“South Bay did an amazing job power washing my house, fence, shed and patios.”
Free estimatesLicensed & insuredSince 2016Serves Dix Hills, Commack +3Veteran-owned
East Islip, NY · 4 mi from Bay Shore
i
East Island Painting

East Island Painting

5.0 36 reviews
“They removed old wallpaper and painted several rooms, and everything looks great.”
Free estimatesServes Suffolk County, North Fork, The HamptonsSince 2014
Ronkonkoma, NY · 8 mi from Bay Shore
i
Dan Bozzo Spackling

Dan Bozzo Spackling

5.0 138 reviews
“Excellent Job on time workers very professional and polite price was very reasonable very happy with the service will recommend will use again have no worries to use Dan's team.”
Free consultationSince 2012
Huntington, NY · 11 mi from Bay Shore
i
Ghassan's Painting & Wallcovering

Ghassan's Painting & Wallcovering

4.0 1 review
Free estimatesInsuredServes Suffolk County, Nassau CountyLicensedSince 1998
Smithtown, NY · 9 mi from Bay Shore
i
Buildingli.com Construction Services

Buildingli.com Construction Services

5.0 25 reviews
“I've worked with a lot of different handymen/contractors and I can't commend them enough.”
LicensedSince 2018
Plainview, NY · 12 mi from Bay Shore
i
Bill Johnson Painting Inc

Bill Johnson Painting Inc

5.0 17 reviews
“The work was done meticulously and they were extremely careful and neat while they did their work.”
Free consultationSince 2015
West Sayville, NY · 8 mi from Bay Shore
i
AV Spackling

AV Spackling

5.0 2 reviews
Free consultationInsuredServes Long IslandLicensedSince 2019
West Babylon, NY · 6 mi from Bay Shore
i
Integrated Drywall & Construction

Integrated Drywall & Construction

5.0 2 reviews
“Prompt, good quality, attention to detail, great customer service”
Free consultationSince 2020Family-owned
Amityville, NY · 9 mi from Bay Shore
i

Compare Drywall & Plaster Contractors near Bay Shore, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC5.0 · 238 reviews · East Islip
Surgical Prep Painting · Power Washing · estate restorationSince 2016Homes · Businesses
The Paint Pros5.0 · 81 reviews · Bohemia
painting · staining · sheetrock repairHomes · Businesses
East Island Painting5.0 · 36 reviews · Ronkonkoma
interior painting · exterior painting · cabinet paintingSince 2014Homes
La Clave Home Improvements5.0 · 69 reviews · Farmingdale
Since 2020
Green Apple Painting & Wallpaper4.9 · 103 reviews · Greenwich
Since 2013
Conrad Painting5.0 · 41 reviews · Huntington
Since 2008
Valdez Painting Co.4.9 · 65 reviews · Amityville
Interior painting · Exterior painting · Cabinet painting32+ yearsHomes · Businesses
Dan Bozzo Spackling5.0 · 138 reviews · Huntington
Since 2012
Turner's Painting LLC5.0 · 51 reviews · Huntington
Since 2008
Buildingli.com Construction Services5.0 · 25 reviews · Plainview
residential and commercial constructionSince 2018
AV Spackling5.0 · 2 reviews · West Babylon
Spackling · Sheetrocking · Interior paintingSince 2019
Bill Johnson Painting Inc5.0 · 17 reviews · West Sayville
Since 2015
Ghassan's Painting & Wallcovering4.0 · 1 review · Smithtown
Interior painting · Exterior painting · Wallpaper removalSince 1998
Integrated Drywall & Construction5.0 · 2 reviews · Amityville
Since 2020
B & B Painting By the Pro's4.9 · 28 reviews
Since 2004

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo business pays us. Nobody can buy a listing, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedWe leave out permanently closed businesses, call centers posing as local contractors and duplicate branches.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, certifications and years in business come from each company's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Drywall & Plaster Contractors we compared 439 businesses in and around Bay Shore. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then businesses in Bay Shore, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top