Best Real Estate Agents in Bay Shore, NY

15 firms listed · all 15 in Bay Shore · 2 open 24/7 · 12 open weekends · 14 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 11, 2026

Power Team Realty Corp

Power Team Realty Corp

4.7 65 reviews
“Thank you so much for helping us find our new home we could not have done this without you and we are endlessly grateful for you hard work and expertise”
Free consultationLicensedSince 2005Family-ownedSe habla español
1813 5th Ave
i
Ramsay Realtors

Ramsay Realtors

4.8 46 reviews
“From the initial consultation to closing, their communication was transparent and timely, keeping me informed every step of the way.”
Since 1987
236 W Main St
i
Leonard

Leonard "lenny" Simonetti

5.0 94 reviews
“Such a good experience -I used them twice!”
Serves Long Island, Nassau County, Suffolk CountySince 2016Financing
269 W Main St 2nd Floor
i
Christian Velez

Christian Velez

4.9 27 reviews
“If you want someone who knows what he's doing and straight forward and honest Christian is your real estate person.”
Open 24 hoursSince 2020Prices online
1680 Manatuck Blvd
i
The Kenville Prince Experience

The Kenville Prince Experience

5.0 14 reviews
“Difficult to part with and impossible to forget our moments.”
Since 2021
1363 5th Ave
i
Joesiann Cortez

Joesiann Cortez "your Personal Agent"

5.0 19 reviews
“Her open house led to multiple offers which she screened and then presented them to me .”
Since 2020
300 Suburban Ave
i

Listed for buyers and sellers in and around Bay Shore, NY, these 15 firms are real estate agents. What each one says about its coverage, its specialties and the side of a deal it takes comes from its own website, alongside ratings and quotes from public reviews.

Hiring a real estate agent in Bay Shore

All 15 firms we list here are in Bay Shore itself. 14 of the firms on this page have a rating, from 4.7 to 5.0 across 400 reviews; 3 have 50 or more reviews.

How many listed agents publish a website?

Of the 15 firms on this page, all 15 give a website. Look past the photography at the sold listings: how many, how recent, and how close to your address. An agent whose site shows nothing sold in your neighborhood is worth asking about directly.

Colleen Colasacco at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty

Colleen Colasacco at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty

5.0 8 reviews
“She quickly internalized the specs we were looking for and constantly sent us options that both fit the bill precisely and were pretty close, but which based on her experience she surmised we might still want to see.”
Since 2019
249 W Main St
i
Arbo Realty

Arbo Realty

5.0 6 reviews
“They are very professional and genuinely care about their customers and those involved in the transaction.”
Since 2012
1391 Brentwood Rd
i
Jonathan Valet

Jonathan Valet

5.0 5 reviews
“Once we found my wife's dream home, he guided us on on the bidding process leading us to beat out 9 other buyers.”
Open 24 hoursSince 2002
1531 Brentwood Rd
i
Kyle Roskot Realtor

Kyle Roskot Realtor

5.0 4 reviews
“However, our elation turned to disappointment when we learned that the seller's realtor had sold the house to someone else for $5,000 more, without any prior communication.”
Since 2024
61 W Main St suite 102
i
Prince & Associates

Prince & Associates

5.0 2 reviews
“Angela Prince and her staff are wonderful, easy to talk to and highly knowledgeable in all things real estate!”
Since 2018
1363 5th Ave
i
Herrick Real Estate

Herrick Real Estate

5.0 1 review
“Bobby Herrick and the entire team at Herrick Real Estate were absolutely amazing to me and my wife throughout our home-buying journey.”
Since 2012
119 E Main St
i
Pace Real Estate Services

Pace Real Estate Services

Since 2012
1555 Sunrise Hwy
i
Market Match Real Estate

Market Match Real Estate

4.9 6 reviews
“From the moment we told Carolina what we were looking for she understood our priorities and made it her job to find us our dream home.”
Since 2021
7 W Main St Ste B
i
Margarita Burgos

Margarita Burgos

5.0 4 reviews
“The best of the best achieving the great dream of your first home is better than it sounds and they make it possible with excellent attention and always in the face of any setback ask for the best MARGARITA BURGOS.”
Since 2005
1535 Brentwood Rd
i
HomeRealtorsNew YorkBay Shore, NY

Compare Real Estate Agents in Bay Shore, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
Leonard "lenny" Simonetti5.0 · 94 reviews
Since 2016
Ramsay Realtors4.8 · 46 reviews
Since 1987
Christian Velez4.9 · 27 reviews
Since 2020
Joesiann Cortez "your Personal Agent"5.0 · 19 reviews
Since 2020
Power Team Realty Corp4.7 · 65 reviews
Since 2005
The Kenville Prince Experience5.0 · 14 reviews
Since 2021
Colleen Colasacco at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty5.0 · 8 reviews
Since 2019
Arbo Realty5.0 · 6 reviews
Since 2012
Jonathan Valet5.0 · 5 reviews
Since 2002
Margarita Burgos5.0 · 4 reviews
Since 2005
Pace Real Estate ServicesNo rating yet
Since 2012
Market Match Real Estate4.9 · 6 reviews
Since 2021
Kyle Roskot Realtor5.0 · 4 reviews
Since 2024
Prince & Associates5.0 · 2 reviews
Since 2018
Herrick Real Estate5.0 · 1 review
Since 2012

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo business pays us. Nobody can buy a listing, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedWe leave out permanently closed businesses, call centers posing as local contractors and duplicate branches.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, certifications and years in business come from each company's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Realtors we compared 4,418 businesses in and around Bay Shore. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then businesses in Bay Shore, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top