Best Real Estate Agents near West Babylon, NY

We have 3 firms in West Babylon on file. Only the highest-rated make our list: 2 of them made it, along with 13 from Babylon (9, 1 mi), North Babylon (2, 2 mi) and West Islip (2, 3 mi).

4 open 24/7 · 11 open weekends · 11 rated 4.5+ · 2 show a license

Data verified November 6, 2026

Nexthome Orangedot Real Estate

Nexthome Orangedot Real Estate

4.9 29 reviews
“They are experts in their field - work diligently, offer great response time, and are quick to take action.”
Coupons & offersOpen 24 hoursSince 1994Virtual consultations
1029 Little East Neck Rd
i
Netter Real Estate

Netter Real Estate

4.6 75 reviews
“Debra Carr was our real estate agent, she is not only knowledgeable, but friendly and helpful.”
Since 1952
West Islip, NY · 3 mi from West Babylon
i
Irene Siconolfi

Irene Siconolfi

5.0 37 reviews
“Irene is a true professional, I have worked with Irene for many years on real-estate transactions, she is very knowledgeable, and has a true passion for real estate, her experience is second to none”
Open 24 hoursSince 2022
Babylon, NY · 1 mi from West Babylon
i
Doreen Manzo- BHG Real Estate

Doreen Manzo- BHG Real Estate

5.0 27 reviews
“Knows her profession and is willing to put in the effort and time to make her clients happy!!!!”
MLS# 38065544Open 24 hoursSince 2009
Babylon, NY · 1 mi from West Babylon
i
First Liberty Real Estate

First Liberty Real Estate

4.3 16 reviews
“He helped me Buy the house and have been taking care of my rentals ever since.”
LicensedOpen 24 hoursSince 2006
North Babylon, NY · 2 mi from West Babylon
i
Damianos Realty Group

Damianos Realty Group

4.5 18 reviews
“Office gets very busy but they all handle this patiently and the best they can.”
Since 1999Family-owned
500 W Main St
i

Listed for buyers and sellers in and around West Babylon, NY, these 15 firms are real estate agents. What each one says about its coverage, its specialties and the side of a deal it takes comes from its own website, alongside ratings and quotes from public reviews.

Hiring a real estate agent near West Babylon

13 of the 15 firms on this page have a rating, from 4.0 to 5.0 across 362 reviews; 1 has 50 or more reviews and 11 are rated 4.5 or higher. We count these figures across the firms on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the firm before you book.

Why are some listings here based outside West Babylon?

2 of the 15 firms are based in West Babylon; the rest come from other towns within 5 mi. An agent from the next town over can be fine if they sell here regularly. Ask which of their recent closings were in West Babylon itself.

Lisa Miglino

Lisa Miglino

5.0 31 reviews
“Lisa always listened to my concerns and needs and continuously kept in touch while doing it with a smile.”
Babylon, NY · 1 mi from West Babylon
i
Carlene Calabrese

Carlene Calabrese

5.0 25 reviews
“Carlene is going to listen, be available, be transparent, make sure you're prepared and make sure you know what to expect.”
MLS# 38065544Since 2009Financing
Babylon, NY · 1 mi from West Babylon
i
Fran Azzilonna Shesh

Fran Azzilonna Shesh

5.0 18 reviews
“If you want someone who will make you feel like family during the entire process (which is not an easy one given the current market) Fran is the one!”
Since 2009
Babylon, NY · 1 mi from West Babylon
i
Eden 7 Realty

Eden 7 Realty

4.0 1 review
“They will do more than you expect them to.”
Since 2015
North Babylon, NY · 2 mi from West Babylon
i
Leading Edge Real Estate Services

Leading Edge Real Estate Services

5.0 8 reviews
“Jennifer is the absolute best when it comes to an agent so are Mandy and Jenny if you're considering buying or selling this as the best place to go”
20+ years
Babylon, NY · 1 mi from West Babylon
i
Shannon Heyman

Shannon Heyman

5.0 3 reviews
“Her quick responses and assistance made the process of selling my home feel seamless.”
Since 2022Virtual consultations
West Islip, NY · 3 mi from West Babylon
i
Caroline Pavlik

Caroline Pavlik

5.0 7 reviews
“Caroline provides invaluable advice that fosters trust, even if you're navigating the process from a distance outside the state of New York, as I was at the time of the sale or close by in New York.”
Babylon, NY · 1 mi from West Babylon
i
Realty Connect USA

Realty Connect USA

Since 2018
Babylon, NY · 1 mi from West Babylon
i
Katter Real Estate Services

Katter Real Estate Services

Since 2022
Babylon, NY · 1 mi from West Babylon
i
HomeRealtorsNew YorkWest Babylon, NY

Compare Real Estate Agents near West Babylon, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
Irene Siconolfi5.0 · 37 reviews · Babylon
Since 2022
Doreen Manzo- BHG Real Estate5.0 · 27 reviews · Babylon
Since 2009
Nexthome Orangedot Real Estate4.9 · 29 reviews
Since 1994
Carlene Calabrese5.0 · 25 reviews · Babylon
Since 2009
First Liberty Real Estate4.3 · 16 reviews · North Babylon
Since 2006
Fran Azzilonna Shesh5.0 · 18 reviews · Babylon
Since 2009
Netter Real Estate4.6 · 75 reviews · West Islip
Since 1952
Leading Edge Real Estate Services5.0 · 8 reviews · Babylon
20+ years
Realty Connect USANo rating yet · Babylon
Since 2018
Katter Real Estate ServicesNo rating yet · Babylon
Since 2022
Caroline Pavlik5.0 · 7 reviews · Babylon
Damianos Realty Group4.5 · 18 reviews
Since 1999
Lisa Miglino5.0 · 31 reviews · Babylon
Shannon Heyman5.0 · 3 reviews · West Islip
Since 2022
Eden 7 Realty4.0 · 1 review · North Babylon
Since 2015

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo business pays us. Nobody can buy a listing, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedWe leave out permanently closed businesses, call centers posing as local contractors and duplicate branches.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, certifications and years in business come from each company's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Realtors we compared 4,516 businesses in and around West Babylon. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then businesses in West Babylon, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top