Best Roofing Contractors in Bay Shore, NY

15 companies listed · 6 in Bay Shore · 5 open 24/7 · 12 open weekends · all 15 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 8, 2026

Roof Pro

Roof Pro

5.0 54 reviews
“The crew was neat and professional, and Scott and Steve were there for us through the whole process.”
Coupons & offersFree estimatesServes Long Island, Nassau County +4Family-ownedBBB accreditedSince 1989
21 Washington Ave
i
Premium Roofing & Siding

Premium Roofing & Siding

5.0 43 reviews
“I contacted the owner, Phil, this morning regarding an emergency repair for a gutter that had detached from my home, and the issue was fully resolved by 4:00 PM.”
Free estimatesServes Suffolk CountyBBB accreditedOpen 24 hours
31 Bay Shore Ave
i
American Side Home Improvement

American Side Home Improvement

5.0 50 reviews
“I would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for home improvement services and would use them again in the future!”
Insured & bondedServes Bay Shore, NY, Brightwaters, NY +420+ years
1667 Pine Grove Blvd
i
Keenridge Construction Corp.

Keenridge Construction Corp.

5.0 26 reviews
“They left everything neat and were very courteous and professional.”
Free consultationOpen 24 hoursSince 2023
1409 Chicago Ave
i
B&E Pro Construction Corp

B&E Pro Construction Corp

5.0 2 reviews
“One of the fastest and well respected workers I've seen, work quality is amazing can repair up to any roofing damages like leaks , skylights , shingle , flat roofs (etc).”
Free estimates20+ yearsOpen 24 hoursFamily-owned
4 Fern Ave
i
Sheet Metal Shop Inc

Sheet Metal Shop Inc

5.0 4 reviews
“Both Carl and Rob are extremely helpful and always understand what I need”
InsuredSince 1983Serves Long IslandLicensed
36 Redington St
i

Listed for homeowners in and around Bay Shore, NY, these 15 companies take roofing work. What each one claims about tear-offs, materials and workmanship cover is taken from its own website; ratings and quoted lines come from public reviews.

Hiring a roofer in Bay Shore

Of the 15 companies we list here, 6 are in Bay Shore itself and 9 come from towns including West Babylon (2, 6 mi), Hauppauge (1, 6 mi) and Holbrook (1, 9 mi). The companies on this page are rated from 4.5 to 5.0 across 2,443 reviews; 10 have 50 or more reviews. The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "price", "estimates" and "cleanliness". We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book.

In New York

  • Home improvement contractors must be licensed in New York City and in Suffolk, Nassau, Westchester, Putnam and Rockland counties.
  • Your home improvement contract must be in writing, legible and in plain English, with a copy given to you before any work is done.
  • You can cancel a home improvement contract in writing, for any reason, until midnight of the third business day after you sign.

Attorney General fact sheet and Attorney General hiring guide, checked November 2026

Why are some of these roofers based elsewhere?

An address in Bay Shore itself is given by 6 of the 15 companies; the rest work in from within 15 mi. Roofing crews travel, so that is normal. What matters is whether the firm will still be around and reachable when the workmanship warranty is tested.

New York rules for hiring a contractor
Before you call: what to check and what to ask
Above All Roofing

Above All Roofing

4.8 19 reviews
“I used Above All Roofing to install a new skylight They did a great job The men cleaned up and I couldn't be more pleased about the install I will use them for any other projects I need”
35+ yearsServes Bay Shore, NYFree consultationLicensedFamily-owned
Brookhaven, NY · 17 mi from Bay Shore
i
Four Seasons Roofing & Exteriors

Four Seasons Roofing & Exteriors

4.9 82 reviews
“They helped with everything I asked for, along with some additional requests that came up while onsite.”
Coupons & offersFree consultationLicensedSince 2015Family-ownedFinancing
Farmingdale, NY · 10 mi from Bay Shore
i
Ned Stevens Gutter Cleaning

Ned Stevens Gutter Cleaning

4.6 106 reviews
“I was especially impressed with how they were able to custom fabricate each gutter onsite.”
$25 offSame-day responseSince 1965Serves Staten Island, Nassau +4Free consultationBBB accredited
Hauppauge, NY · 6 mi from Bay Shore
i
Dormer King

Dormer King

4.6 45 reviews
“Dormer King completed a shell extension off the back of our home, redid the siding, and added a portico on our home over the Summer, and My wife and I could not have been happier with the work they completed.”
Free consultationSince 1972Serves Long IslandFamily-ownedBBB A+
West Babylon, NY · 6 mi from Bay Shore
i
J. Great Roofing

J. Great Roofing

4.9 107 reviews
“Henry and his crew were skilled and efficient.”
Free consultationBBB accreditedSince 1993Locally ownedPrices online
West Babylon, NY · 6 mi from Bay Shore
i
Long Island Construction .com

Long Island Construction .com

4.5 44 reviews
“They were always available to address any questions or concerns that I might have had due the whole process.”
Free estimatesInsured0% financing21+ yearsServes Long Island, Suffolk County, Nassau CountyBBB A+
Holbrook, NY · 9 mi from Bay Shore
i
Perfect Pitch Roofing

Perfect Pitch Roofing

4.9 100 reviews
“Professional, respectful, quality work and considerate of your property”
Free consultationBBB A+Since 2017
Brookhaven, NY · 17 mi from Bay Shore
i
Mici Construction

Mici Construction

5.0 69 reviews
“They did a excellent job installing my new roof and even threw in gutters for free.”
Free consultationSince 2019
Nesconset, NY · 9 mi from Bay Shore
i
Sumrick Builders

Sumrick Builders

4.8 55 reviews
“The quality of work is fantastic and I would highly recommend Sumrick to anyone looking for quality work and dependable service.”
BBB A+Since 2014
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY · 10 mi from Bay Shore
i
HomeRoofing ContractorsNew YorkBay Shore, NY

Compare Roofing Contractors in Bay Shore, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
B&E Pro Construction Corp5.0 · 2 reviews
Commercial and residential roofing · Roofing installation20+ years
Ned Stevens Gutter Cleaning4.6 · 106 reviews · Hauppauge
gutter cleaning · gutter repair · gutter installationSince 1965
Above All Roofing4.8 · 19 reviews
New roof installation · Roof repairs35+ years
Long Island Construction .com4.5 · 44 reviews · Holbrook
Roofing · Siding · Decks21+ years
Roof Pro5.0 · 54 reviews
Since 1989
Premium Roofing & Siding5.0 · 43 reviews
roof repair and replacement · siding repair and replacement
Four Seasons Roofing & Exteriors4.9 · 82 reviews · Farmingdale
Since 2015
Keenridge Construction Corp.5.0 · 26 reviews
Since 2023
Dormer King4.6 · 45 reviews · West Babylon
dormers · extensions · second-story additionsSince 1972
Mici Construction5.0 · 69 reviews · Nesconset
Since 2019
American Side Home Improvement5.0 · 50 reviews
Roofing installation and repairs · Siding20+ years
J. Great Roofing4.9 · 107 reviews · West Babylon
Since 1993
Perfect Pitch Roofing4.9 · 100 reviews
Since 2017
Sheet Metal Shop Inc5.0 · 4 reviews
HVAC duct work · Commercial hood and Code 96 installationSince 1983
Sumrick Builders4.8 · 55 reviews · Lake Ronkonkoma
Since 2014

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo business pays us. Nobody can buy a listing, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedWe leave out permanently closed businesses, call centers posing as local contractors and duplicate branches.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, certifications and years in business come from each company's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Roofing Contractors we compared 1,558 businesses in and around Bay Shore. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then businesses in Bay Shore, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top