Best Home Builders in St. Augustine, FL

17 contractors listed · all 17 in St. Augustine · 5 open weekends · 15 rated 4.5+ · 3 show a license

Data verified October 18, 2026

Home Synergy Construction & Remodeling

Home Synergy Construction & Remodeling

4.9 44 reviews
“If you like first class workmanship, first class quality, first class professional service and first class finished product ,look no further than this wonderful company!”
LicensedSince 2019
585 International Golf Pkwy Ste 6
i
Trailmark Living

Trailmark Living

4.7 38 reviews
“The neighborhood is tucked away far enough to not hear busy traffic and a perfect location to see all the natural wildlife that still resides in the landscape throughout the neighborhood.”
Since 2014Virtual consultations
805 Trailmark Dr
i
Brandon Construction

Brandon Construction

5.0 24 reviews
“Beau was able to provide tremendous insight as to local and federal ordinances, the special constructions needs to be considered in building on the beach, estimates, and thoughts on some of the available lots in the area.”
Since 2007
7 Arenta St
i
Tri-State Builders & Remodeling LLC

Tri-State Builders & Remodeling LLC

4.8 19 reviews
“To encounter a smile and STILL comprehend the ramblings of a frantic, inexperienced homeowner is a testament to your character and stoic-like professionalism in the face of apprehensive-esque panic.”
LicensedSince 2019Locally owned
107 Marshall Cir
i
Saint Augustine Home Improvements

Saint Augustine Home Improvements

5.0 24 reviews
“Augustine Home Improvements given his excellent reputation; the quality of his portfolio; the insight he brought to preliminary discussions; and the thoroughness of his proposal, which detailed every aspect of the project and its corresponding budget.”
Since 2019
5331 Soundview Ave
i
Cottage Home Company

Cottage Home Company

4.9 16 reviews
“We searched for over a year for our lot and visited with multiple builders and Cottage is the only true custom luxury builder we found in the area who was above all others in the product and experience in building our dream "forever" home.”
Since 2009
610 Market St
i

Listed for people planning a new house in and around St. Augustine, FL, these 17 contractors build on land you own or on lots they control. A card reflects the way that builder describes its own work, its plans and its service area; the ratings beside it come from public reviews.

Area overview: St. Augustine, FL

All 17 contractors we list here are in St. Augustine itself. We have 19 contractors in St. Augustine on file; this page shows the highest-rated 17. The contractors on this page are rated from 4.0 to 5.0 across 328 reviews; 2 have 50 or more reviews and 15 are rated 4.5 or higher. 5 are open on Saturdays and 2 on Sundays. 3 show a license on their websites. 10 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 25 years. 1 gives free estimates and 2 are family- or locally-owned. We have a website on file for 15 of the contractors on this page; 13 publish a contact page; 13 list a public email and 1 takes bookings online. We count these figures across the contractors on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the contractor before you book.

What should I look for on a builder's site?

Websites are listed for 15 of the 17 builders on this page. Look for houses finished years ago rather than renderings, a named list of the plans they build, and a clear statement of which counties they work in. A gallery with no addresses and no plans is a portfolio you cannot check.

Forrest Builders

Forrest Builders

4.8 14 reviews
“We brought an unusual design to them that included an unusual set of wants/needs during a difficult market time (early in Covid era) and they executed the construction in a professional and conscientious way.”
Since 2013
171 Riberia St
i
Antigua By Dream Finders Homes

Antigua By Dream Finders Homes

4.0 12 reviews
“Stunning apartments and a fantastic development!!”
Since 2008
St Barts Ave
i
TLC Home Saint Augustine

TLC Home Saint Augustine

4.5 14 reviews
“Great energy came when the TLC truck arrived at our home, consistently, even with the unrelated and unforeseen issues (leak found in the ceiling, A/C froze, Portolet truck tore up yard)---- TLC took care of things beyond the job description.”
Free consultationLicensedSince 2019Locally owned
137 Egret Rd
i
Dotson Development

Dotson Development

5.0 1 review
“I've had him do multiple remodels and additions to different properties and they have all turned out great.”
Since 2012
3125 #B US1 South
i
Shoreland Home Builders

Shoreland Home Builders

4.0 1 review
“We were extremely happy and had never worked with a builder that was so organized, honest, and truly enthused about what he was doing.”
Since 2016
2525 Dobbs Rd
i
Farwood Home and Design

Farwood Home and Design

5.0 4 reviews
“Many thanks to you for a great experience you provided and prompt turn around in building our home.”
Since 2009
38 Hannah Cole Dr
i
Finial Custom Builders

Finial Custom Builders

10-yr warrantyServes Northeast FloridaSince 2012
155 St Johns Business Pl STE 202
i
Build For Life Co

Build For Life Co

25+ years
238 W King St
i
Ocean View Custom Home Builder

Ocean View Custom Home Builder

5.0 3 reviews
“If you are looking for a kitchen remodeler, don't hesitate to go with Ocean View Custom Home Builders!”
Since 2020
6896 A Avenue
i
Sapp Builders Inc.

Sapp Builders Inc.

7625 US-1
i
Forrest Inc

Forrest Inc

238 W King St #1
i
HomeHome BuildersFloridaSt. Augustine, FL

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top