Carnegie Management Inc.
“Great management company - any issues I had were resolved extremely quickly and they were extremely caring to me not only as a tenant, but as a person.”
Best Property Managers in Brooklyn, NY
24 companies listed · all 24 in Brooklyn · 4 open 24/7 · 13 open weekends · 18 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 18, 2026
BJD Property Management
“The team, led by Dion, is doing an exceptional job with our property in Brooklyn.”
Foot Soldiers
“They work outside without needing you to be home so you can just relax knowing your garbage will be taken out!”
Mypropertyman
“Not only is the team knowledgable, detailed and efficient, they are super responsive, clear communicators, and quick to bring qualified vendors to the discussion when issues arise and repairs are urgently needed.”
Newport Street Capital Property Management
“We were in desperate need of relocation, and Jaime expedited everything, flying in like a guardian angel.”
Leiter Property Management
“Leiter manages our building in Brooklyn and are doing a great job.”
Listed for property owners in and around Brooklyn, NY, these 24 companies manage rental property. What each says about the property types it takes, the services in its fee and its license is drawn from its own website, next to ratings and quotes from public reviews.
Area overview: Brooklyn, NY
All 24 companies we list here are in Brooklyn itself. We have 82 companies in Brooklyn on file; this page shows the highest-rated 24. The companies on this page are rated from 4.0 to 5.0 across 924 reviews; 4 have 50 or more reviews and 18 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these companies on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (98%), responsiveness (93%) and quality (80%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "communication" and "efficient". 4 are open around the clock; 12 are open on Saturdays and 11 on Sundays. 2 show a license on their websites and 2 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 14 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 32 years. 4 offer emergency call-outs; 5 give free estimates and 3 are family- or locally-owned. We have a website on file for all 24 of the companies on this page; 20 publish a contact page; 19 list a public email and 1 takes bookings online. We count these figures across the companies on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book.
Do any property managers listed for Brooklyn take overnight calls?
Around the clock cover is stated by 4 of the 24 companies on this page. For an owner that phone line is the product, because a burst supply line at 3 a.m. is your loss and not the tenant's. Ask who actually picks up, whether it is an answering service, and which trades can be sent out overnight.
Guardian Property Management
“Jeff and his team have been a reliable presence for our weekly and monthly needs as well as when bigger issues or projects arise.”
Ranco Management
“The super and management were quick to respond to requests and resolve issues.”
ABS Management
“Impeccable service truly a pleasure, dealt with reuven nicest guy around communicating and getting it all done efficiently.”
Two Trees Management
“Our building and amenities are excellent, and it's so nice being able to walk into the management office with questions since they are located just across the street.”
Olympic Property Management
“I've been a resident in one of their queens properties for 6 months so far and management has always been accessible and easy to reach for all maintenance requests.”
Brooklyn Property Management
“They handle tenant issues swiftly and keep the building well-maintained, which is a relief for us tenants.”
Prorealty Property Management
“Collaborating with Vince from Pro Realty on our cleaning project was truly a positive experience.”
Brickway Management
“The best of all the rental companies, they are serious and if you have any questions or problems they look for the fastest way to solve...”
ET General Construction Inc.
“They were very thoughtful in suggesting ways to use the space more efficiently and the quality of the work was excellent.”
Narrows Management
“We have had a very positive experience with Narrows managing our building, with JR and Selma providing especially strong communication, responsiveness, and being helpful to our needs.”
Kaito Services LLC
“Steven Baker does a fantastic job managing our condo building and is responsible for completing many capital improvement and repair projects.”
The Bellslip
“Anything that I ever needed help with personally Andi and Damian at the front desk were always able and willing to help me.”
Noble Property Management
“Owner is very responsive and quick to address any issues that are brought up.”
Boyer Partners Property Management
“They go above and beyond to make sure your property is taken care of and the tenants are happy.”
Good Peoples Property Management
“We moved into an older brown stone that had some issues that come with older buildings, and when it came to doing repairs or checking on issues we could not have asked for a better building manager.”
Archetive Property Management Inc.
“Have nothing but good experiences with them.”
Silver Brick Management
“I had a few days between renters and Silver Brick could accommodate my specific needs — a repaint of part of a kitchen wall that previous renters had damaged, and also an apartment-wide deep-clean.”
Redstone Realty NYC
“When we needed to break our lease early they were very helpful with the entire process of finding a new tenant.”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
