Fort Myers, FL

Popular Cities

Fort Myers, FL
Join as a Pro

Best Property Managers in Fort Myers, FL

24 companies listed · 21 in Fort Myers · 1 open 24/7 · 7 open weekends · 17 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 14, 2026

View Profile
Rentifi Property Management

Rentifi Property Management

(46)
  • Investment
  • Check
  • Responsive
“I have had a very good experience with that office and Alex takes care of me very well every time I call, very attentive and very good customer service”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 1992
BBB Rating: A+
Cash only
2830 Winkler Ave #103-A, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
All County Medallion Property Management

All County Medallion Property Management

(41)
  • Questions
  • Cost
  • Understanding
“While the house hasn't needed much in the way of maintenance service (5years old) they use an online service I log into, and the maintenance requests get a prompt response and it's convenient and easy to use.”
In Business Since 2003
BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
2726 Oak Ridge Ct # 501, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Real Property Management Instant Equity

Real Property Management Instant Equity

(45)
  • Knowledge
  • Industry
  • Expertise
“Daniel at RP Management rental services was very responsive to the client's needs and help them clean up their disaster situation I was very impressed the way he handled the situation.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 1993
BBB Accredited
Accepts Cash, Check
5237 Summerlin Commons Blvd, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Rental Link

Rental Link

(46)
  • Quality
  • Message
  • Call
“Andrea Gutierrez is always on top of things, very good at getting back to me and checks in to makes sure things are okay and taken care of after any issues.”
In Business Since 2007
Transparent Fees & Pricing
3414 Forum Blvd Suite 2, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Royal Palm Property Management Inc.

Royal Palm Property Management Inc.

(42)
  • Lease
  • Mind
  • Attention
“Thank you very much for your attention, Lame a couple of times and Miguel helped me, he was very clear in explaining the process and requirements as well as being kind.”
In Business Since 2021
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Transparent Fees & Pricing
813 Lake McGregor Dr, Fort Myers, FL
FAQs
Q: Do you sell real estate too?
We are a full service real estate company helping investors from all over the world. Property management is a service that we offer and have a team dedicated to just that. We also have agents that specialized in sales and listings as well.
Q: Can I say who I want as tenants for my property?
You can specify whether or not you want tenants with pets (in most situations) or even tenants who don't smoke although all our properties are marketed as smoke-free. However, the more restrictive you are, the longer it could take to rent your property. You cannot discriminate against any protected class under the federal fair housing or local fair housing laws, such as saying you don't want children. Because of this, it is best that you leave the selection process to us. We are professionals in
Q: What do I need to do to my property before I rent it?
The better condition your property is in, the better quality tenant we will attract for you. This means that the property should be clean, carpeting should be shampooed, walls should be painted (a neutral color is best) if they are dirty or marred,
Q: How is maintenance handled?
The tenants do have responsibility for some of the maintenance on your property. They have to replace burnt out light bulbs, change furnace filters, change batteries in the smoke detectors, and provide for exterminating if they are in a single family
Q: What type of insurance do I need?
Your normal homeowners' insurance does not extend to you the same coverage you will need when you rent out your house. You need comprehensive public liability insurance also known as DP3 - Dwelling Property All Risk. It still gives you the fire coverage you get from your homeowners but adds extended coverage since you will have a tenant living in the house. Expect this added coverage to increase your premium some. We recommend you speak with your insurance agent before you rent out your house.
Get the answers to more questions on the FAQ page on our website.
i
View Profile
Cushman & Wakefield

Cushman & Wakefield

(47)
  • Questions
  • Integrity
  • Communication
“Hanna was SUPER easy and fun to work with, she made the process of my commercial lease very simple and I would recommend her to anyone looking to expand or change their business location.”
In Business Since 2012
5220 Summerlin Commons Blvd STE 500, Fort Myers, FL
i

Listed for property owners in and around Fort Myers, FL, these 24 companies manage rental property. What each says about the property types it takes, the services in its fee and its license is drawn from its own website, next to ratings and quotes from public reviews.

Area overview: Fort Myers, FL

Of the 24 companies we list here, 21 are in Fort Myers itself and 3 come from North Fort Myers (2, 7 mi). The companies on this page are rated from 4.0 to 5.0 across 1,568 reviews; 8 have 50 or more reviews and 17 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these companies on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (96%), responsiveness (88%) and quality (71%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "communication", "efficient" and "price". 1 is open around the clock; 7 are open on Saturdays and 2 on Sundays. 2 show a license on their websites and 6 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 11 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 53 years. 1 offers emergency call-outs; 1 gives free estimates and 3 are family- or locally-owned. We have a website on file for 23 of the companies on this page; 20 publish a contact page; 19 list a public email and 3 take bookings online. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book.

How many listed property managers say they are licensed?

2 of the 24 listings for Fort Myers show a license on their websites. Ask for the number and take it to the state regulator and confirm it is current and actually covers property management. Ask separately about the trust account and the fidelity bond, because a license on its own tells you nothing about how your rent is held.

View Profile
Keyrenter Fort Myers Property Management

Keyrenter Fort Myers Property Management

(48)
  • Expertise
  • Investor
  • Mind
“Providing a comprehensive turnkey service, Keyrenter Fort Myers is exceptionally attentive, making it the ideal choice for those seeking a property management firm that effectively relieves you of the burdens of property management, allowing you to f...”
In Business Since 2022
9160 Forum Corporate Pkwy Suite, 350, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Malt Realty & Development

Malt Realty & Development

(45)
  • Communication
  • Deposit
  • Questions
“Very professional experience, I will say like never before , here is not about money , is about service, if you agree with me , is not often available, Thank you !”
In Business Since 1973
1614 Colonial Blvd #102, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Alliance Realty Group

Alliance Realty Group

(11)
  • Price
  • Home
  • Meeting
“Debra paid attention to all the details and included them well in the description, she took fabulous pictures to include and spread the information very effectively.”
In Business Since 2007
BBB Rating: A+
14090 Metropolis Ave, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Seagate Development Group

Seagate Development Group

(7)
  • Sales
  • Money
  • Project
“On point from first meeting to project completion.”
In Business Since 2018
Licensed
9921 Interstate Commerce Dr, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Pro Management Realty LLC

Pro Management Realty LLC

(22)
  • Future
  • Communicative
  • Landlord
“Hello guys , i am very proud and happy about the job that Cossette and team pro management did with my House and specially the care they took about me in the whole process .”
In Business Since 2018
15550 McGregor Blvd # 204, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Uptown Property Services

Uptown Property Services

(20)
  • Questions
  • Home
  • Rented
“It was a tough journey, with storms and the biggest hurricane to hit SW Florida in decades, causing delays completing repairs/improvements before the sale.”
In Business Since 2015
2400 First St Unit 212, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Grow Care Outdoor Solutions

Grow Care Outdoor Solutions

(13)
  • Company
  • Job
“Jose was absolutely amazing, I asked for an estimate to pull trees in my yard and plant royal palms and I had mentioned that I just had Curbing put in my yard and had not yet kill the grass on the insides of the Curbing.”
In Business Since 2019
Average Price Tag
Free Initial Consultation
17940 N Tamiami Trl #110, North Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Sun Watch Swfl

Sun Watch Swfl

(11)
  • Second Home
  • Worry
  • Contractors
“Over the years, my family and I have stayed at lots of different properties, but we've never had a property management experience like Greg at Sun Watch.”
In Business Since 2020
Family Business
14290 Hampton Lake Ct, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
NXT LVL Property Management

NXT LVL Property Management

(10)
  • Rental
“Jessica and I spoke several times about my rental property but I decided to try on my own but she was very professional and followed up and gave me great market analysis.”
Family Business
In Business Since 2023
Licensed
Transparent Fees & Pricing
2256 First St Suite #146, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Check My Home

Check My Home

(14)
  • Inspection
  • Report
  • Attention
“He also has contacted my service people (with my permission) when my air conditioner needed attention and he met them at the house when they came to service the unit.”
In Business Since 2018
Locally Owned & Operated
19622 Tesoro Way, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
FHR Property Management

FHR Property Management

(8)
  • Renting
“I have nothing less than my utmost confidence in their service and professionalism”
In Business Since 2012
12557 New Brittany Blvd Suite 3, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Lee County Evictions and Rent Recovery

Lee County Evictions and Rent Recovery

(1)
“Working with Lee County Evictions was awesome as they took care of everything (eviction, cradle to grave) including changing the locks and waiting with the Sheriff while the tenants were escorted out the door”
In Business Since 2023
Emergency Services
1617 Hendry St #409a, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Anchor Property Services

Anchor Property Services

(10)
“Have been with them for 5 years , never have had a problemwith them, everytime we have needed something fixed never had to wait more than an hour for a response and problem was always fixed some day ,”
In Business Since 2015
8595 College Pkwy suite 350, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Swfl Gulfside Properties Inc.

Swfl Gulfside Properties Inc.

(5)
  • Home
  • Rental
“My wife and I feel confident that our investment property is in very good hands as evidenced by the tenant selection process and how promptly and efficiently any and all issues have been managed.”
In Business Since 2021
Transparent Fees & Pricing
12734 Kenwood Ln #77, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Province Property Home Watch

Province Property Home Watch

(8)
  • Clean
“Nicole from Province Property Group does an amazing job cleaning my home!!”
In Business Since 2022
8971 Baytowne Loop, Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Rentfix Property Management Inc. Dba Newgen Realty

Rentfix Property Management Inc. Dba Newgen Realty

(6)
  • Market
  • Team
“As a new remote house owner in the Cape Coral area, I feel secure to have Rentfix looking after my property and look forward to have Sean and his team market my new house as one of the Premiere Vacation home rental in the Cape region.”
In Business Since 2020
8359 Beacon Blvd #401, Fort Myers, FL
Featured

Rent Fix is a new way to manage your properties that guarantees rent every month! We take over the management and marketing of your property, so you don't have to worry about it anymore. You can sit back, relax, and know that we are taking care of everything for you. All you need to do is hire us! Call us now!

i
View Profile
Cyrus International Realty Corporation

Cyrus International Realty Corporation

(26)
  • Short Sale
  • Communicate
  • Respect
“I'm sure Mohsen and his group have much more expensive listings but he treated this one as I imagine he treats any other transaction and not as if it was a waste of his time for such a small deal, which I appreciated immensely.”
Fort Myers, FL
i
View Profile
Old Bridge Village Co-Op Exercise

Old Bridge Village Co-Op Exercise

(6)
  • Amenities
“Great place to live.”
In Business Since 2002
2501 New Post Rd, North Fort Myers, FL
i
HomeProperty ManagersFloridaFort Myers, FL

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?

More Property Managers in Florida

Popular in Fort Myers

, FL
Back To Top