Best Real Estate Agents in Rochester, NY

23 firms listed · all 23 in Rochester · 5 open 24/7 · 17 open weekends · 21 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 11, 2026

Norchar Real Estate

Norchar Real Estate

5.0 95 reviews
“She's very knowledgeable, and I definitely recommend her if you're interested in getting a real estate agent.”
License #10991215417Serves Rochester, Monroe CountyVeteran-ownedBBB A+Since 2018
389 Park Ave
i
Torres Turn Key Property Management

Torres Turn Key Property Management

4.3 100 reviews
“In my opinion, it is one of the best property management companies in Rochester.”
BBB A+Since 2020
645 Norton St
i
Sharon Quataert Team With Century 21 Apex

Sharon Quataert Team With Century 21 Apex

4.9 120 reviews
“After working with her I realized not all real estate agents are the same.”
Serves Rochester, NYOpen 24 hoursSince 1985Financing
1239 University Ave Ste 1A
i
WCI Realty

WCI Realty

4.8 86 reviews
“I highly recommend hiring her as your real estate agent you won't regret it.”
BBB A+Since 2015
2450 W Ridge Rd #202
i
Anthony Butera Team at Keller Williams Realty

Anthony Butera Team at Keller Williams Realty

4.9 136 reviews
“Jeff worked so hard for us to help us find our home and was so helpful and responsive great experience and would recommend him to anyone and already have”
Open 24 hoursSince 2016
1770 Long Pond Rd
i
G & M Properties

G & M Properties

4.0 42 reviews
“I will truly miss my long relationship with G&M Properties after my property sale, but I can safely and confidently assure any potential landlord or tenant that this management company is the best.”
LicensedServes Rochester, Finger LakesBBB A+Since 2011
2024 W Henrietta Rd STE 3A
i

Listed for buyers and sellers in and around Rochester, NY, these 23 firms are real estate agents. What each one says about its coverage, its specialties and the side of a deal it takes comes from its own website, alongside ratings and quotes from public reviews.

Hiring a real estate agent in Rochester

All 23 firms we list here are in Rochester itself. We have 116 firms in Rochester on file; this page shows the highest-rated 23. The firms on this page are rated from 4.0 to 5.0 across 4,026 reviews; 17 have 50 or more reviews and 21 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the firms on this page are "communication", "knowledge" and "price".

How many listed agents publish a website?

Of the 23 firms on this page, all 23 give a website. Look past the photography at the sold listings: how many, how recent, and how close to your address. An agent whose site shows nothing sold in your neighborhood is worth asking about directly.

The Property Girls Team

The Property Girls Team

4.9 98 reviews
“I flip homes with my family and have worked with several real estate agents over the years, but once we started working with The Property Girls, that was it for us.”
Serves Monroe, Wayne, OntarioLicensedSince 2009Virtual consultations
644 South Ave
i
The Dawn Nowak Team

The Dawn Nowak Team

5.0 109 reviews
“I want to share my sincere appreciation for the wonderful experience working with Dawn and Jim.”
Since 2018Virtual consultations
2000 S Winton Rd #201
i
Dave Baxter Realty

Dave Baxter Realty

4.9 43 reviews
“His experience and expertise were apparent throughout the entire process, and the insights he shared were invaluable.”
Coupons & offersLicensedSince 2016Virtual consultations
709 Seneca Pkwy
i
The Nathan Wenzel Team

The Nathan Wenzel Team

5.0 84 reviews
“The Nathan Wenzel Team was always available and made buying a new home and selling our old home go seamlessly.”
Since 2018
2349 Monroe Ave
i
The GC Homes Team

The GC Homes Team

4.9 95 reviews
“I want to express my sincere gratitude to my real estate agent, Laura Pfleuger, and my executive assistant, Heather, for their outstanding support throughout the home-buying process.”
Since 2021
2850 W Ridge Rd
i
Bespoke Homes Team at Keller Williams Realty

Bespoke Homes Team at Keller Williams Realty

5.0 112 reviews
“She educated us on the market, provided us with staging guidance and best practices for showings.”
Free phone consultationSince 2012Serves Greater Rochester, Pittsford +7Licensed
2000 S Winton Rd Bldg 1, suite 201
i
The Belpanno's on Team Luxe

The Belpanno's on Team Luxe

4.9 87 reviews
“They assisted us in what we needed to do and what wasn't worth doing to get the house ready to list.”
Since 2020
1770 Long Pond Rd
i
Team Hilbert at Keller Williams Realty

Team Hilbert at Keller Williams Realty

5.0 118 reviews
“When documentation on the home was provided and the banks and appraiser needed more Andy helped me gather all that was needed.”
Serves Monroe County, Greater Rochester +3Since 2008
2000 S Winton Rd #201
i
The Jeff Scofield Team Real Estate Agents

The Jeff Scofield Team Real Estate Agents

5.0 144 reviews
“She is super attentive and goes above and beyond to help her clients find their dream home!”
Since 1999
2171 Monroe Ave
i
Alan Wood

Alan Wood

4.9 95 reviews
“He goes above and beyond to get you the most money for your house.”
Serves Rochester New YorkNMLS #959951Since 2021
2171 Monroe Ave
i
Elysian Homes by Mark Siwiec and Associates

Elysian Homes by Mark Siwiec and Associates

4.9 149 reviews
“Would definitely recommend him to anyone, and if we happen to need a real estate agent again, we will undoubtedly turn to him.”
Since 2023
1357 Monroe Ave
i
Scott Barrows (Realtor)

Scott Barrows (Realtor)

5.0 48 reviews
“I highly recommend him if you are either looking to purchase a home or sell.”
License #10401283983Serves Rochester, Monroe CountySince 2021
2000 S Winton Rd #201
i
The Rick Borrelli Team

The Rick Borrelli Team

4.9 37 reviews
“With young children and a busy schedule, selling a home could have been chaotic — but Jenna worked around our needs, respected our routines, and made sure every decision aligned with what was best for our family.”
Open 24 hoursSince 2019
2450 W Ridge Rd #308
i
Jonathan Pecora Realtor With the Pecora Team

Jonathan Pecora Realtor With the Pecora Team

5.0 36 reviews
“With Jonathan we were able to have private appointments and when we did attend open houses he was right there with us.”
LicensedSince 1995
2000 S Winton Rd Bldg 1 suite 201
i
Strategic Partners Team

Strategic Partners Team

4.9 42 reviews
“Our agent, Laura Swogger, was friendly, knowledgeable, and ever-ready to offer advice and counsel, often going out of her way to inspect a property for us.”
MLS# 38065544Open 24 hoursSince 2022Financing
2000 Winton Rd #201
i
Tracey Dedee

Tracey Dedee

5.0 35 reviews
“She advocated for me every step of the way, and helped me find the perfect house.”
LicensedOpen 24 hoursSince 1995
2171 Monroe Ave
i
Gary Norselli at Keller Williams Realty

Gary Norselli at Keller Williams Realty

4.9 45 reviews
“I have worked with him multiple times over a number of years and he delivers nothing but the best.”
15+ yearsServes Rochester, Hilton +13
1770 Long Pond Rd
i
HomeRealtorsNew YorkRochester, NY

Compare Real Estate Agents in Rochester, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
Team Hilbert at Keller Williams Realty5.0 · 118 reviews
Home buying · Home sellingSince 2008Homes
Bespoke Homes Team at Keller Williams Realty5.0 · 112 reviews
home-buying services · home-selling servicesSince 2012Homes
Anthony Butera Team at Keller Williams Realty4.9 · 136 reviews
Since 2016Homes
The Property Girls Team4.9 · 98 reviews
home buying · home selling · home estimatesSince 2009Homes
Norchar Real Estate5.0 · 95 reviews
Buying and selling residential real estateSince 2018Homes
The Nathan Wenzel Team5.0 · 84 reviews
Home purchase and sale assistanceSince 2018
Sharon Quataert Team With Century 21 Apex4.9 · 120 reviews
Since 1985
The GC Homes Team4.9 · 95 reviews
Home buying representation · Home selling representationSince 2021
Alan Wood4.9 · 95 reviews
home buying · home sellingSince 2021
Tracey Dedee5.0 · 35 reviews
Since 1995
Dave Baxter Realty4.9 · 43 reviews
Home-selling marketingSince 2016
Strategic Partners Team4.9 · 42 reviews
Since 2022
The Rick Borrelli Team4.9 · 37 reviews
Since 2019
The Jeff Scofield Team Real Estate Agents5.0 · 144 reviews
Since 1999
The Dawn Nowak Team5.0 · 109 reviews
Since 2018
Scott Barrows (Realtor)5.0 · 48 reviews
Since 2021
The Belpanno's on Team Luxe4.9 · 87 reviews
Since 2020
Jonathan Pecora Realtor With the Pecora Team5.0 · 36 reviews
Since 1995
Gary Norselli at Keller Williams Realty4.9 · 45 reviews
Buying or selling a property · Relocation15+ years
Elysian Homes by Mark Siwiec and Associates4.9 · 149 reviews
Since 2023
WCI Realty4.8 · 86 reviews
Since 2015
G & M Properties4.0 · 42 reviews
Property management · Real estate representationSince 2011
Torres Turn Key Property Management4.3 · 100 reviews
Since 2020

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo business pays us. Nobody can buy a listing, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedWe leave out permanently closed businesses, call centers posing as local contractors and duplicate branches.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, certifications and years in business come from each company's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Realtors we compared 332 businesses in and around Rochester. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then businesses in Rochester, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top