Best Real Estate Agents in Ithaca, NY

20 firms listed · all 20 in Ithaca · 2 open 24/7 · 12 open weekends · 18 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 8, 2026

Kate Seaman Team at Warren Real Estate

Kate Seaman Team at Warren Real Estate

5.0 48 reviews
“Their resources and vendor contacts were very helpful in getting our home ready in time.”
Since 2010
830 Hanshaw Rd
i
Steven Saggese / Associate Broker at Warren Real Estate

Steven Saggese / Associate Broker at Warren Real Estate

5.0 99 reviews
“He is resourceful, knowledgeable, and was able to find us a buyer soon after we started working with him.”
MLS# 408957Since 2002
140 Seneca Way
i
PJ Apartments

PJ Apartments

4.9 58 reviews
“The management team is extremely responsive and always quick to address any questions or maintenance requests.”
Since 2012
202 Williams St
i
Realtor

Realtor

4.9 25 reviews
“Melynda did a magnificent job of getting us ready to put our home on the market, staging our home for listing, and helping us sell our home at a price we were happy with.”
MLS# 407702Since 2008
140 Seneca Way
i
Laurel Guy

Laurel Guy

5.0 8 reviews
“She knows the market exceptionally well, is consistently warm and upbeat and gives spot on and highly valuable professional and practical advice for the unanticipated issues that seem always to arise.”
Open 24 hoursSince 2005
140 Seneca Way
i
James Orcutt Real Estate

James Orcutt Real Estate

5.0 26 reviews
“I don't think we could have found a better property manager in Ithaca.”
Since 2005
324 Dryden Rd Unit 2
i

Listed for buyers and sellers in and around Ithaca, NY, these 20 firms are real estate agents. What each one says about its coverage, its specialties and the side of a deal it takes comes from its own website, alongside ratings and quotes from public reviews.

Hiring a real estate agent in Ithaca

All 20 firms we list here are in Ithaca itself. We have 21 firms in Ithaca on file; this page shows the highest-rated 20. 19 of the firms on this page have a rating, from 4.0 to 5.0 across 355 reviews; 3 have 50 or more reviews and 18 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the firms on this page are "knowledge" and "responsive".

How many listed agents publish a website?

Of the 20 firms on this page, all 20 give a website. Look past the photography at the sold listings: how many, how recent, and how close to your address. An agent whose site shows nothing sold in your neighborhood is worth asking about directly.

The Jill Burlington Team at Warren Real Estate

The Jill Burlington Team at Warren Real Estate

4.9 9 reviews
“Despite the market being flooded with homes, Jill still found a buyer for my home within a short amount of time while other houses sat with no interest.”
Since 2006
830 Hanshaw Rd
i
Heather Gowe

Heather Gowe

5.0 4 reviews
Since 2020
602 W State St
i
Diana Drucker

Diana Drucker

5.0 3 reviews
“Her patience was unwavering as we viewed property after property for months, but most importantly, she gleaned what we were looking for before we could even articulate it for ourselves and encouraged us to hold steady and keep looking when she could have sold us properties that would have allowed her to move onto other clients and walk away with a higher check.”
Since 1996
1187 E Shore Dr
i
Linz Real Estate

Linz Real Estate

5.0 3 reviews
“Linz showed me some houses and was very well prepared and thoroughly answered all of my questions and was extremely knowledgeable”
LicensedSince 2006
9 Evergreen Ln
i
Key Brokers

Key Brokers

5.0 1 review
“I've worked with Chris and team several times and they are exceptional!”
Since 2016
3432, 950 Danby Rd #208
i
Lama Commercial Real Estate

Lama Commercial Real Estate

5.0 1 review
“The team was supportive, easy to communicate with, and helped me throughout the process.”
Since 2017
2343 N Triphammer Rd
i
Cornell Business & Technology

Cornell Business & Technology

4.7 1 review
Since 1999
15 Thornwood Dr # 7
i
Jolene Rightmyer-Macolini Team

Jolene Rightmyer-Macolini Team

5.0 1 review
“We feel we really lucked out with such a helpful and friendly realtor, and highly recommend working with her for your selling & buying needs.”
Since 2003
119 E Buffalo St
i
Ryan C. Mitchell

Ryan C. Mitchell

Open 24 hoursSince 1997
140 Seneca Way Suite 200
i
Ithaca Apartment Company

Ithaca Apartment Company

Since 2007
428 N Titus Ave
i
Jala Bayo @ Berkshire Hathaway Heritage Realty

Jala Bayo @ Berkshire Hathaway Heritage Realty

5.0 3 reviews
Since 2008
119 E Buffalo St
i
Ahir Real Estate

Ahir Real Estate

5.0 2 reviews
“Both Karan and Pratik are highly knowledgable in commercial real estate and make the process of buying or selling much easier.”
MLS # 123456Since 2022
638 Elmira Rd
i
Realty Management Concepts

Realty Management Concepts

5.0 1 review
Since 2008
200 Lower Creek Rd
i
Ithaca Board of Realtors Inc

Ithaca Board of Realtors Inc

Since 1998
957 Mitchell St
i
HomeRealtorsNew YorkIthaca, NY

Compare Real Estate Agents in Ithaca, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
Steven Saggese / Associate Broker at Warren Real Estate5.0 · 99 reviews
Since 2002
Kate Seaman Team at Warren Real Estate5.0 · 48 reviews
Since 2010
James Orcutt Real Estate5.0 · 26 reviews
Since 2005
Realtor4.9 · 25 reviews
Since 2008
Laurel Guy5.0 · 8 reviews
Since 2005
The Jill Burlington Team at Warren Real Estate4.9 · 9 reviews
Since 2006
Heather Gowe5.0 · 4 reviews
Since 2020
PJ Apartments4.9 · 58 reviews
Since 2012
Diana Drucker5.0 · 3 reviews
Since 1996
Jala Bayo @ Berkshire Hathaway Heritage Realty5.0 · 3 reviews
Since 2008
Jolene Rightmyer-Macolini Team5.0 · 1 review
Since 2003
Ryan C. MitchellNo rating yet
Since 1997
Ithaca Apartment CompanyNo rating yet
Since 2007
Linz Real Estate5.0 · 3 reviews
Since 2006
Ahir Real Estate5.0 · 2 reviews
Since 2022
Key Brokers5.0 · 1 review
Since 2016
Lama Commercial Real Estate5.0 · 1 review
Since 2017
Realty Management Concepts5.0 · 1 review
Since 2008
Cornell Business & Technology4.7 · 1 review
Since 1999
Ithaca Board of Realtors IncNo rating yet
Since 1998

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo business pays us. Nobody can buy a listing, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedWe leave out permanently closed businesses, call centers posing as local contractors and duplicate branches.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, certifications and years in business come from each company's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Realtors we compared 350 businesses in and around Ithaca. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then businesses in Ithaca, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top