Best Real Estate Agents in Utica, NY

15 firms listed · 9 in Utica · 3 open 24/7 · 9 open weekends · 13 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 8, 2026

Assist2sell Buyer's & Seller's 1st Choice

Assist2sell Buyer's & Seller's 1st Choice

4.9 113 reviews
“Marty sold my home quickly, with multiple offers; he is efficient, and was very kind and patient with me.”
Open 24 hoursSince 2001Prices online
2704 Genesee St
i
Coldwell Banker Faith Properties

Coldwell Banker Faith Properties

5.0 136 reviews
“We were very nervous about all the process of buying our fist home but Ela's attitude made all this process so easy.”
Since 2015
2811 Genesee St
i
Property Sisters of the Mohawk Valley

Property Sisters of the Mohawk Valley

5.0 6 reviews
“She follows through on everything and isn't satisfied until her clients are!”
Open 24 hours35+ years
2811 Genesee St
i
Buy Sell Rent Realty

Buy Sell Rent Realty

5.0 7 reviews
“Very professional and helped my family every step of the way.”
Since 2023
2222 Oriskany St W
i
The John Brown Team at Coldwell Banker Faith Properties

The John Brown Team at Coldwell Banker Faith Properties

4.7 12 reviews
“He has been an amazing source of information, and has guided me in choosing the right tenants.”
Since 2003
2811 Genesee St
i
Brian A Gaetano Co

Brian A Gaetano Co

Since 2012
258 Genesee St #201
i

Listed for buyers and sellers in and around Utica, NY, these 15 firms are real estate agents. What each one says about its coverage, its specialties and the side of a deal it takes comes from its own website, alongside ratings and quotes from public reviews.

Hiring a real estate agent in Utica

Of the 15 firms we list here, 9 are in Utica itself and 6 come from towns including New Hartford (3, 4 mi), Whitesboro (1, 4 mi) and Marcy (1, 5 mi). The firms on this page are rated from 4.1 to 5.0 across 1,018 reviews; 4 have 50 or more reviews and 13 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the firms on this page are "knowledge" and "communication". We count these figures across the firms on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the firm before you book.

How many listed agents publish a website?

Of the 15 firms on this page, all 15 give a website. Look past the photography at the sold listings: how many, how recent, and how close to your address. An agent whose site shows nothing sold in your neighborhood is worth asking about directly.

Signature Realty Inc

Signature Realty Inc

Since 2009
16 Bank Pl
i
Brockway-Carpenter Real Estate LLC

Brockway-Carpenter Real Estate LLC

5.0 5 reviews
“For a first-time homebuyer, he made the process as simple as possible and explained everything to me that I didn't understand.”
Free consultationSince 2020Prices online
288 Genesee St
i
Ronald Stewart Mohawk Valley 1st Choice Realty

Ronald Stewart Mohawk Valley 1st Choice Realty

4.1 5 reviews
“If you are interested in buying a house, give them a call”
Since 2013
2604 Genesee St
i
Coldwell Banker Sexton Real Estate

Coldwell Banker Sexton Real Estate

5.0 61 reviews
“The best place to go when shopping for real estate!”
Open 24 hoursSince 2014Family-ownedFinancing
Clinton, NY · 8 mi from Utica
i
Pavia Real Estate Residential

Pavia Real Estate Residential

5.0 99 reviews
“She genuinely cared for our concerns and took the time to answer the millions of questions we'd ask her.”
Since 2011
New Hartford, NY · 4 mi from Utica
i
Century 21 One Realty

Century 21 One Realty

4.9 33 reviews
“Works very hard to find the right fit for you and your family, while also answering every question for you at every step of the way.”
Since 2017
New Hartford, NY · 4 mi from Utica
i
Home Pro Realty

Home Pro Realty

4.8 10 reviews
“They answered all my questions and educated me on them.”
Since 2018
Whitesboro, NY · 4 mi from Utica
i
Weichert Realtors

Weichert Realtors

4.5 4 reviews
“You did an awesome job, you are professional and fast responding to my texts, called, etc… I recommend to everyone who looking to buy a house call him you will not be disappointed.”
Since 2015
New Hartford, NY · 4 mi from Utica
i
Track Side Limited Partnership

Track Side Limited Partnership

Since 2010
Marcy, NY · 5 mi from Utica
i
HomeRealtorsNew YorkUtica, NY

Compare Real Estate Agents in Utica, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
Coldwell Banker Sexton Real Estate5.0 · 61 reviews · Clinton
Since 2014
Assist2sell Buyer's & Seller's 1st Choice4.9 · 113 reviews
Since 2001
Pavia Real Estate Residential5.0 · 99 reviews · New Hartford
Since 2011
Property Sisters of the Mohawk Valley5.0 · 6 reviews
35+ years
Century 21 One Realty4.9 · 33 reviews · New Hartford
Since 2017
Coldwell Banker Faith Properties5.0 · 136 reviews
Since 2015
Buy Sell Rent Realty5.0 · 7 reviews
Since 2023
Home Pro Realty4.8 · 10 reviews · Whitesboro
Since 2018
Brockway-Carpenter Real Estate LLC5.0 · 5 reviews
Since 2020
Ronald Stewart Mohawk Valley 1st Choice Realty4.1 · 5 reviews
Since 2013
The John Brown Team at Coldwell Banker Faith Properties4.7 · 12 reviews
Since 2003
Weichert Realtors4.5 · 4 reviews · New Hartford
Since 2015
Brian A Gaetano CoNo rating yet
Since 2012
Signature Realty IncNo rating yet
Since 2009
Track Side Limited PartnershipNo rating yet · Marcy
Since 2010

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo business pays us. Nobody can buy a listing, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedWe leave out permanently closed businesses, call centers posing as local contractors and duplicate branches.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, certifications and years in business come from each company's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Realtors we compared 174 businesses in and around Utica. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then businesses in Utica, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top