Best Home Builders near Bay Shore, NY

1 of these contractors is based in Bay Shore; the others serve Bay Shore from towns including West Babylon (6 mi), Farmingdale (10 mi) and Massapequa Park (11 mi).

6 open weekends · 14 rated 4.5+ · 4 show a license

Data verified November 4, 2026

DKP Wood Railings and Stairs

DKP Wood Railings and Stairs

5.0 97 reviews
“Artur handled all of the measurements and was incredibly helpful throughout the entire process.”
Free estimatesLicensed & insuredSince 2001Serves New York City, Nassau County +3Family-owned
1971 Union Blvd
i
Cascella and Sons Construction Corp

Cascella and Sons Construction Corp

4.8 77 reviews
“Whenever we called, he picked up the phone always there checking to make sure that the job was done to perfection …if we Had a concern he was excellent at troubleshooting and fix the problem.”
Andersen-certifiedFinancing availableServes Long IslandBBB A+Since 2000
Central Islip, NY · 5 mi from Bay Shore
i
Fortitude Contracting

Fortitude Contracting

4.8 74 reviews
“Kelly provided direct communication for project costs and was always able to clarify and questions we had almost immediately, she was always professional, organized, and easy to work with.”
Free consultationLicensedSince 2017Family-owned
West Babylon, NY · 6 mi from Bay Shore
i
C&S Long Island Contractor Dormers Specialist

C&S Long Island Contractor Dormers Specialist

4.8 62 reviews
“It's clear they take pride in the quality build and craftsmanship.”
Insured500+ projects completedServes Nassau County, Suffolk CountyFree consultationLicensedSince 2011
Farmingdale, NY · 10 mi from Bay Shore
i
TCR Builders

TCR Builders

5.0 64 reviews
“They communicated every step of the project, they were always available to answer all my questions and concerns.”
Free estimates20+ yearsServes Nassau County, NY, Suffolk County, NY
West Babylon, NY · 6 mi from Bay Shore
i
Noah Construction & Builders

Noah Construction & Builders

4.7 98 reviews
“The work was so impressive that, even though renovating wasn't remotely on my radar at the time, the contractor's sign on the lawn stuck in my memory: Noah Construction.”
35+ yearsServes Nassau County, NY, Suffolk County, NY, Long IslandBBB accreditedInsurance accepted
Bohemia, NY · 8 mi from Bay Shore
i

Listed for people planning a new house in and around Bay Shore, NY, these 15 contractors build on land you own or on lots they control. A card reflects the way that builder describes its own work, its plans and its service area; the ratings beside it come from public reviews.

Hiring a home builder near Bay Shore

The 15 contractors on this page are rated from 4.2 to 5.0 across 881 reviews; 9 have 50 or more reviews and 14 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the contractors on this page are "price", "communication" and "crew". We count these figures across the contractors on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the contractor before you book.

In New York

  • If your contractor doesn't have the required insurance, you could be held liable for a worker's injury or for damage caused on your property.

Attorney General fact sheet and Attorney General hiring guide, checked November 2026

Which builders here say they are licensed?

4 of the 15 listings shown show a license on their websites. For new houses, ask separately who provides the structural warranty and get that in writing, since the company standing behind the house for a decade is not always the company that built it.

New York rules for hiring a contractor
MJF Home Upgrades Inc.

MJF Home Upgrades Inc.

5.0 96 reviews
“Frank was the perfect project manager, keeping us informed of all the work that was being performed, answering any questions we had, and always letting us know what to expect next.”
Free estimatesLicensedFinancing availableSince 2016Serves Nassau County, western Suffolk CountyFamily-owned
Massapequa Park, NY · 11 mi from Bay Shore
i
Book onlineBook
R&A Custom Decks

R&A Custom Decks

4.9 77 reviews
“I had no problems at all as my wife and i were VERY HAPPY with the work they did and how it all came out looking .”
Serves Long Island, Amityville +4Free consultationSince 2020
Amityville, NY · 9 mi from Bay Shore
i
Center Island Contracting

Center Island Contracting

4.6 73 reviews
“Always explains in full detail all that work being done and when it will be completed.”
Since 2008
Farmingdale, NY · 10 mi from Bay Shore
i
Silver Fox Construction

Silver Fox Construction

5.0 41 reviews
“Working with Rob Nock was a great experience - good communication, kept the work area clean, and pacing of the job.”
Since 2010
East Northport, NY · 12 mi from Bay Shore
i
MK Home Improvement LLC

MK Home Improvement LLC

5.0 40 reviews
“They are professional, do amazing work, are on time, complete the projects in a timely fashion, and are extremely fair in their pricing.”
Since 2022
Massapequa Park, NY · 11 mi from Bay Shore
i
John J Contracting

John J Contracting

4.9 33 reviews
“I liked the way the job was run, they assign a Forman who is in contact with you regularly and they have skilled craftsman to do the work.”
Free estimates20+ years
Huntington Station, NY · 11 mi from Bay Shore
i
Murtha Construction

Murtha Construction

4.2 13 reviews
“I was prepared with a few names, but I felt confident after having the audit done and meeting with Michael Storey that this company had my best interest in mind.”
InsuredWarranty on all workSince 1986BBB accredited
West Islip, NY · 3 mi from Bay Shore
i
Bilello Construction

Bilello Construction

5.0 7 reviews
“Extremely easy to work with and outcomes in my experiences have always been positive.”
Free estimatesServes Suffolk County, Long IslandSince 1983
East Islip, NY · 3 mi from Bay Shore
i
Straight Line Construction

Straight Line Construction

5.0 29 reviews
“What was especially amazing was he was always calm when it called for it.”
Free consultationLicensedSince 1990
St James, NY · 11 mi from Bay Shore
i
HomeHome BuildersNew YorkBay Shore, NY

Compare Home Builders near Bay Shore, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
DKP Wood Railings and Stairs5.0 · 97 reviews
Railing Manufacturing · Stairs ManufacturingSince 2001Homes
MJF Home Upgrades Inc.5.0 · 96 reviews · Massapequa Park
kitchen remodeling · bathroom remodelingSince 2016
R&A Custom Decks4.9 · 77 reviews · Amityville
new deck construction · deck repairs and restorationSince 2020
John J Contracting4.9 · 33 reviews · Huntington Station
Custom home building · General contracting20+ yearsHomes · Businesses
C&S Long Island Contractor Dormers Specialist4.8 · 62 reviews · Farmingdale
Window work · Siding · Water damage restorationSince 2011Homes · Businesses
TCR Builders5.0 · 64 reviews · West Babylon
Home extensions and additions20+ years
Straight Line Construction5.0 · 29 reviews · St James
Since 1990
Cascella and Sons Construction Corp4.8 · 77 reviews · Central Islip
bathroom remodeling · kitchen remodeling · custom deckingSince 2000
Fortitude Contracting4.8 · 74 reviews · West Babylon
Since 2017
Bilello Construction5.0 · 7 reviews · East Islip
new home construction · house extensions · dormersSince 1983
MK Home Improvement LLC5.0 · 40 reviews · Massapequa Park
Since 2022
Noah Construction & Builders4.7 · 98 reviews · Bohemia
complete home remodeling · new homes · extensions35+ years
Silver Fox Construction5.0 · 41 reviews · East Northport
Since 2010
Murtha Construction4.2 · 13 reviews · West Islip
kitchen remodeling · bathroom remodeling · home additionsSince 1986
Center Island Contracting4.6 · 73 reviews · Farmingdale
Since 2008

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo business pays us. Nobody can buy a listing, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedWe leave out permanently closed businesses, call centers posing as local contractors and duplicate branches.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, certifications and years in business come from each company's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Home Builders we compared 818 businesses in and around Bay Shore. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then businesses in Bay Shore, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top