Best Property Managers in Rochester, NY

22 companies listed · all 22 in Rochester · 2 open 24/7 · 5 open weekends · 6 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 11, 2026

Torres Turn Key Property Management

Torres Turn Key Property Management

4.3 100 reviews
“In my opinion, it is one of the best property management companies in Rochester.”
BBB A+Since 2020
645 Norton St
i
G & M Properties

G & M Properties

4.0 42 reviews
“I will truly miss my long relationship with G&M Properties after my property sale, but I can safely and confidently assure any potential landlord or tenant that this management company is the best.”
LicensedServes Rochester, Finger LakesBBB A+Since 2011
2024 W Henrietta Rd STE 3A
i
Eastman Property Management

Eastman Property Management

4.1 23 reviews
“Christian, Lindsay and the crew at Eastman Property Management have been managing my rental property in Rochester for nearly 4 years.”
BBB A+Since 2011Prices online
2024 W Henrietta Rd
i
Yourway Properties

Yourway Properties

4.8 52 reviews
“This team knows how to produce solid results for property owners.”
Since 2016
125 Indigo Creek Dr
i
Updegraff Management

Updegraff Management

4.0 69 reviews
“Attentive to tenant needs, respectful, decent pricing.”
Since 2014
1039 Monroe Ave
i
Rochester Property Solutions

Rochester Property Solutions

4.2 95 reviews
“Fred has now fixed my water temp and a few outlets, he is always friendly and efficient.”
Since 2017
212 Winton Rd N
i

Listed for property owners in and around Rochester, NY, these 22 companies manage rental property. What each says about the property types it takes, the services in its fee and its license is drawn from its own website, next to ratings and quotes from public reviews.

Hiring a property manager in Rochester

All 22 companies we list here are in Rochester itself. We have 23 companies in Rochester on file; this page shows the highest-rated 22. 20 of the companies on this page have a rating, from 1.0 to 5.0 across 1,042 reviews; 7 have 50 or more reviews and 6 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "communication" and "responsive".

Do any property managers listed for Rochester take overnight calls?

Around the clock cover is stated by 2 of the 22 companies on this page. For an owner that phone line is the product, because a burst supply line at 3 a.m. is your loss and not the tenant's. Ask who actually picks up, whether it is an answering service, and which trades can be sent out overnight.

Flaum Management Co.

Flaum Management Co.

4.0 15 reviews
“We have a beautiful office space and all of our needs are taken care of timely and effectively.”
Since 2000Family-owned
400 Andrews St #500
i
Chauncey Property Management

Chauncey Property Management

4.2 23 reviews
“OG was way more attentive than the last management place was - as far as repairs and the time it took to complete them.”
Since 2023
300 Air Park Dr Ste 80
i
Sell My House Rochester NY

Sell My House Rochester NY

4.8 17 reviews
“From start to finish, he was incredibly respectful, communicative, and genuinely interested in making the process as smooth as possible.”
Open 24 hoursSince 2016
1930 E Main St
i
Proway Management Corporation

Proway Management Corporation

5.0 1 review
“Warning: She is very objective and no pushover, but (credit her for) being solutions minded and came back very next day after the indicated paint deterioration was addressed by me (at her request).”
Since 1989
1164 N Clinton Ave
i
Genesee Management Inc

Genesee Management Inc

Since 1983Family-owned
1265 Scottsville Rd #1
i
Mama Hacs

Mama Hacs

5.0 4 reviews
“When we need assistance with processing rental applications, listings properties and a number of other Property management related tasks.”
Free consultationSince 2019
33 Lisa Ann Dr
i
Park Oxford Properties

Park Oxford Properties

4.4 7 reviews
“Once I was back in the market to look for a new apartment for myself, there was no other group I'd consider than Park oxford properties.”
Since 2015
The Roosevelt, 267 Oxford St
i
Doherty Realty

Doherty Realty

4.4 5 reviews
“Im happy with my apartment in a new neighborhood.”
BBB A+Open 24 hoursSince 1917
1100 University Ave # 201
i
Jake Johnson Properties

Jake Johnson Properties

4.0 3 reviews
“I recommend this place if you want people living next to you that are respectful, accepting and kind regardless of your background.”
Since 2020
274 1/2, 274 Alexander St
i
Brickwood Management

Brickwood Management

4.7 4 reviews
“Clean and a great staff,very accommodating”
Since 2008
25 Silverlight Wy
i
Maguire Properties

Maguire Properties

4.4 4 reviews
“Heaven on earth is Dennis Maguire and his team.”
Since 1982
146 Halstead St
i
Horizon Management

Horizon Management

4.8 2 reviews
“Great support staff in the office.”
40+ years
1320 Buffalo Rd #201
i
Eastside Realty Management

Eastside Realty Management

3.8 10 reviews
“Wendy showed up at 10AM today and promptly and efficiently handled my problem.”
Since 2017
13 Buckingham St
i
Rosey Property Management

Rosey Property Management

Since 2022
18 Lee Rd
i
Custom Realty Management

Custom Realty Management

Since 2004
955 E Henrietta Rd
i
Compson Development

Compson Development

Since 1987
2465 W Ridge Rd
i
HomeProperty ManagersNew YorkRochester, NY

Compare Property Managers in Rochester, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Yourway Properties4.8 · 52 reviews
Mon–Fri 9–5 · Sat 9–5 · Sun 9–5Since 2016
Sell My House Rochester NY4.8 · 17 reviews
24/7Since 2016
Mama Hacs5.0 · 4 reviews
Mon–Fri 9:30–4Since 2019
Torres Turn Key Property Management4.3 · 100 reviews
Mon–Fri 9–5Since 2020
Brickwood Management4.7 · 4 reviews
Mon–Fri 9–4:30Since 2008
Rochester Property Solutions4.2 · 95 reviews
Mon–Fri 9–5Since 2017
Park Oxford Properties4.4 · 7 reviews
Mon–Fri 8–4:30Since 2015
Chauncey Property Management4.2 · 23 reviews
Mon–Fri 10–4 (varies)Since 2023
Doherty Realty4.4 · 5 reviews
24/7Since 1917
Horizon Management4.8 · 2 reviews
Mon–Fri 9–540+ years
Proway Management Corporation5.0 · 1 review
Mon–Fri 24 h · Sat 24 hSince 1989
Eastman Property Management4.1 · 23 reviews
Mon–Fri 9–5Since 2011
G & M Properties4.0 · 42 reviews
Mon–Fri 9–5Since 2011
Updegraff Management4.0 · 69 reviews
Mon–Fri 9–5Since 2014
Flaum Management Co.4.0 · 15 reviews
Mon–Fri 8–5Since 2000
Genesee Management IncNo rating yet
Mon–Fri 9–5 (varies)Since 1983
Jake Johnson Properties4.0 · 3 reviews
Mon–Fri 8–5Since 2020
Rosey Property ManagementNo rating yet
Mon–Fri 9–4Since 2022
Custom Realty ManagementNo rating yet
Mon–Fri 9–4:30Since 2004
Compson DevelopmentNo rating yet
Mon–Fri 9–5 · Sat 9–5 · Sun 9–5Since 1987
Eastside Realty Management3.8 · 10 reviews
Mon–Fri 9–5Since 2017
Maguire Properties4.4 · 4 reviews
Since 1982

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo business pays us. Nobody can buy a listing, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedWe leave out permanently closed businesses, call centers posing as local contractors and duplicate branches.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, certifications and years in business come from each company's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Property Managers we compared 28 businesses in and around Rochester. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then businesses in Rochester, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top