Best Plumbers near Bay Shore, NY

We have 5 contractors in Bay Shore on file. Only the highest-rated make our list: 3 of them made it, along with 12 from towns including Bohemia (3, 8 mi), Ronkonkoma (2, 7 mi) and Farmingdale (2, 10 mi).

10 open 24/7 · 14 open weekends · 14 rated 4.5+ · 8 show a license

Data verified November 4, 2026

Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp

Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp

4.3 39 reviews
“Herber Plumbing fixed the defective brand new Rheem water heater i purchased and had professionally installed.”
$25.00 off any jobLicensed & insured24/7 emergency serviceFinancing availableSince 1971
54 Park Ave
i
All Systems Maintenance

All Systems Maintenance

Since 1986
20 Inez Dr
i
Cronin Plumbing & Heating Inc

Cronin Plumbing & Heating Inc

5.0 4 reviews
“When I had an emergency situation at home my fiancé told me give them a call…So glad I did.”
Since 2005
884 Aberdeen Rd
i
Dashing Dan's Plumbing & Heating Inc.

Dashing Dan's Plumbing & Heating Inc.

4.9 146 reviews
“He was able to remove the old water heater and replace it with a new one...”
$1,000 off boiler replacementInsured & bonded24/7 emergency serviceFinancing availableSince 1961Serves Suffolk County, NY, Nassau County, NY +10
West Islip, NY · 3 mi from Bay Shore
i
Behlen Plumbing & Heating

Behlen Plumbing & Heating

5.0 97 reviews
“They have worked for me many times over the last 20 years from hot water heaters the baseboard heating two bathrooms renovations stump pump I am very happy with everything that they have done.”
Free consultationLicensedOpen 24 hoursSince 2000
Commack, NY · 8 mi from Bay Shore
i
Book onlineBook
Universe Home Services

Universe Home Services

4.8 110 reviews
“It was a pleasure having Nick come to my house to service my gas heater and water heater.”
Coupons & offers24/7 emergency serviceServes Long Island, Rockland County, NY +2LicensedSince 2002Family-owned
Farmingdale, NY · 10 mi from Bay Shore
i

Listed for homeowners in and around Bay Shore, NY, these 15 companies cover plumbing work. Hours, license claims and free estimate offers come from each company's own website, so confirm them on the phone before you agree to a visit for something already running.

Hiring a plumber near Bay Shore

The 15 contractors on this page are rated from 4.3 to 5.0 across 18,740 reviews; 13 have 50 or more reviews and 14 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these contractors on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (90%), responsiveness (85%) and punctuality (79%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the contractors on this page are "price" and "estimates". We count these figures across the contractors on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the contractor before you book.

In New York

  • If your contractor doesn't have the required insurance, you could be held liable for a worker's injury or for damage caused on your property.

Attorney General fact sheet and Attorney General hiring guide, checked November 2026

Why are some of these plumbers based outside Bay Shore?

Bay Shore is the base for 3 of the 15 listings here; the rest come from other towns within 15 mi. Plumbers work across a service area, so a neighboring base is normal. Ask how far the call-out area reaches and whether travel time is billed.

New York rules for hiring a contractor
Before you call: what to check and what to ask
Any Time P & H

Any Time P & H

4.8 71 reviews
“Bill and Matt came to my house for a bathroom faucet and valve replacement.”
Free estimates24/7 emergency serviceSame-day response20+ yearsServes Long Island, NY, Suffolk County, NY, Nassau County, NYFamily-owned
Lindenhurst, NY · 8 mi from Bay Shore
i
Varsity Home Service

Varsity Home Service

4.7 129 reviews
“Our water heater broke and Varsity showed up at 8 am the next morning.”
$50 off first serviceFree consultationSame-day responseFinancing availableSince 1962Serves Long Island
Bohemia, NY · 8 mi from Bay Shore
i
Book onlineBook
Rubber Duck Plumbing Inc.

Rubber Duck Plumbing Inc.

4.7 103 reviews
“Came within the time frame, finished on time, gave me options and were easy to work with.”
Free estimates24/7 emergency serviceSince 2008Serves Oyster BayLicensed
Copiague, NY · 8 mi from Bay Shore
i
Hartmann's & Esposito Plumbing Heating & Air Conditioning

Hartmann's & Esposito Plumbing Heating & Air Conditioning

4.5 44 reviews
“They worked clean and efficient and were thorough , nothing nothing was missed.”
10% offWarranty on all workServes Suffolk County, Nassau CountyMaintenance planBBB accreditedOpen 24 hours
West Babylon, NY · 6 mi from Bay Shore
i
Sam Mechanical Inc

Sam Mechanical Inc

4.9 107 reviews
“They did my water heater first and I called them back to replace my boiler and oil tank.”
Satisfaction guaranteeSince 2008Serves Suffolk County, Nassau CountyOpen 24 hours
Ronkonkoma, NY · 7 mi from Bay Shore
i
Ray the Plumber

Ray the Plumber

4.8 119 reviews
“We had a bathroom faucet that had no water flow at all and they came the same day and had it repaired quickly.”
Coupons & offersFinancing available40+ yearsServes Brookhaven, Suffolk County, Nassau CountyVirtual consultations
Bohemia, NY · 8 mi from Bay Shore
i
Sampson Plumbing & Heating

Sampson Plumbing & Heating

4.8 124 reviews
“They installed a water heater and tuned up my boiler back in June and did a great job.”
$35 off24/7 emergency serviceSince 2009LicensedFamily-owned
Bohemia, NY · 8 mi from Bay Shore
i
Apple Air Heating Cooling Electric and Plumbing

Apple Air Heating Cooling Electric and Plumbing

4.8 139 reviews
“He replaced our water heater main shut-off valve, several other water shut-off valves for the kitchen and bathroom, and also replaced the wax seal on our downstairs toilet.”
Coupons & offersLicensedOpen 24 hoursSince 2010Financing
Farmingdale, NY · 10 mi from Bay Shore
i
Micci Plumbing & Heating

Micci Plumbing & Heating

5.0 122 reviews
“The guys installed a water filtration system for us and installed a new faucet and beverage faucet.”
LicensedOpen 24 hoursSince 2010
Ronkonkoma, NY · 7 mi from Bay Shore
i
HomePlumbing ContractorsNew YorkBay Shore, NY

Compare Plumbers near Bay Shore, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
Dashing Dan's Plumbing & Heating Inc.4.9 · 146 reviews · West Islip
bathtubs · dishwashers · drains24/7Since 1961
Any Time P & H4.8 · 71 reviews · Lindenhurst
Stoppages · Gas line repairs and installation24/720+ years
Rubber Duck Plumbing Inc.4.7 · 103 reviews · Copiague
plumbing · heating · drain cleaning24/7Since 2008
Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp4.3 · 39 reviews
heating and cooling24/7Since 1971
Universe Home Services4.8 · 110 reviews · Farmingdale
HVAC · plumbing · electrical24/7Since 2002
Varsity Home Service4.7 · 129 reviews · Bohemia
Plumbing · Heating · Air conditioningSince 1962
Behlen Plumbing & Heating5.0 · 97 reviews · Commack
Since 2000
Sam Mechanical Inc4.9 · 107 reviews · Ronkonkoma
Air conditioning · Heating services · Geothermal heat pumpsSince 2008
Apple Air Heating Cooling Electric and Plumbing4.8 · 139 reviews · Farmingdale
Since 2010
Sampson Plumbing & Heating4.8 · 124 reviews · Bohemia
plumbing · heating24/7Since 2009
Ray the Plumber4.8 · 119 reviews · Bohemia
Plumbing · Drain cleaning · Cesspool and septic services40+ years
Micci Plumbing & Heating5.0 · 122 reviews · Ronkonkoma
Since 2010
Hartmann's & Esposito Plumbing Heating & Air Conditioning4.5 · 44 reviews · West Babylon
plumbing · heating · air conditioning
Cronin Plumbing & Heating Inc5.0 · 4 reviews
Since 2005
All Systems MaintenanceNo rating yet
Since 1986

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo business pays us. Nobody can buy a listing, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedWe leave out permanently closed businesses, call centers posing as local contractors and duplicate branches.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, certifications and years in business come from each company's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Plumbing Contractors we compared 1,486 businesses in and around Bay Shore. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then businesses in Bay Shore, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

What customers say about contractors near Bay Shore

  • “Great communication and great plumbers. Had a new hot water heater 12 hours after my initial call a few years back.” — customer of Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp
  • “Mike is always there for us. He is prompt, courteous and a valued person for our business.” — customer of Micci Plumbing & Heating
  • “Customer service was excellent. Jayson was extremely professional and thoroughly serviced my hot water heater.” — customer of Varsity Home Service
  • “Awesome service, Tom, Jeff and Mike came and changed out my hot water heater same day on a Saturday.” — customer of Ray the Plumber
  • “Joe was incredibly knowledgeable and was able to assist me with my water heater issue and more.” — customer of Any Time P & H

Excerpts from public reviews of the contractors listed on this page.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top